Game 1 thread
  • 232 posts
  • Page 15 of 16
Jacob24 wrote:
Thanks TLM. I think it would be hard to get something entirely new with how many games y'all have played here :).
"clubs - go suck eggs! :)"
Tennesseelogman, 2024
2ofclubs wrote:
Jacob24
Anyone have feedback for me? I still need to assign roles
MAFIA weighted for win.
It was 99% that he would be last mafia standing with no real threat. "wolf in sheeps clothing" I am not saying he didn't play well or deserve a win.
Faction: Mafia Role: Deciever Income: 4 coins. Add KC's 5 and Thicks 3 coins = 12
Ability: When investigated, you will appear as a townie. If an advanced investigation is used, you will appear as a “Factory Worker”
You add black market abilities, mafia had the Town WC, and new each other D0
While considering Town didn't know each other, faction split and had pre established rabbit hole with neutral.

If TLM and I didn't connect D-Zero with RISK of full discloser, mafia would have turbo steam rolled town and pretty much still did just took longer but yet didn't with the black market extra kill.  Shooting fish in a barrel.
I am not attacking you, it was fun, and you did well moderating the game.
WRKD4IT
Jacob24 wrote:
Rock's ability would have revealed mafia if he didn't use it on the same player each night.
If Mack had saved Crywolf as town asked then it would have been 3v1 in the end.

Mafia opened 0 chats - RED FLAG

Mafia had to spend coins to get town WC and it took them a bit - which is how you ousted Thick and KC

I get the game wasn't perfect, but I don't think it was THAT bad.
"clubs - go suck eggs! :)"
Tennesseelogman, 2024
Jacob24 wrote:
However, I do agree that mafia had an edge and I will be switching some things around next game.
"clubs - go suck eggs! :)"
Tennesseelogman, 2024
2ofclubs wrote:
Jacob24
However, I do agree that mafia had an edge and I will be switching some things around next game.
Yes, I don't know all the behind the scene facts.
Ready to go again!!!!!!!!
WRKD4IT
Crywolf wrote:
If you are ever wondering what role to give me, heres an idea:
Role: God(Neutral)
Ability: Can't be lynched, killed, or eliminated in any ways
Win Condition: Stay alive to the end of the game

Gave it some thought and it seems pretty balanced to me :)
New Mafia game coming
Rockbert wrote:
It's all good Jacob. We had fun and it was your first time hosting so there are bound to be corrections to be made. I wouldn't sweat it. Let's get the next one going. :)
"A writer is a person for whom writing is more difficult than it is for other people."
- Thomas Mann
Jacob24 wrote:
Would we like to play with 7? I can make it work or we can wait a bit more
"clubs - go suck eggs! :)"
Tennesseelogman, 2024
Jacob24 wrote:
Nothing from Ely or Anuorre or Ryo. Can someone ping the others?
"clubs - go suck eggs! :)"
Tennesseelogman, 2024
2ofclubs wrote:
Jacob24
Nothing from Ely or Anuorre or Ryo. Can someone ping the others?
I poked  pygmyhippo277, Abs , Bluegoetz, MacEohaid, elysium5
WRKD4IT
ThickTalon wrote:
Crywolf
If you are ever wondering what role to give me, heres an idea:
Role: God(Neutral)
Ability: Can't be lynched, killed, or eliminated in any ways
Win Condition: Stay alive to the end of the game

Gave it some thought and it seems pretty balanced to me :)


HAHA. I can be Satan if we are playing the Gods game.