Batman mafia game

[quote=pygmyhippo277]your research is admirable KC. 2 things I have noticed so far. Anyone claiming to be a neutral town, is obviously not, they might be concerned citizens but it doesn't seem that there are any neutral "townies" like a normal game. Another thing, there are 19 roles and 18 players, not sure what that means, but I wanted to point it out.[/quote] Yeah pygmy, that is commendable, very observant. Right under our noses. 19/18. Very interesting.

[quote=pygmyhippo277]your research is admirable KC. 2 things I have noticed so far. Anyone claiming to be a neutral town, is obviously not, they might be concerned citizens but it doesn't seem that there are any neutral "townies" like a normal game. Another thing, there are 19 roles and 18 players, not sure what that means, but I wanted to point it out.[/quote] It's quite possible tenn just messed up and one of the concerned citizens isn't in the game, because I would guess their only ability is to vote.

[quote=pygmyhippo277][quote=pygmyhippo277]your research is admirable KC. 2 things I have noticed so far. Anyone claiming to be a neutral town, is obviously not, they might be concerned citizens but it doesn't seem that there are any neutral "townies" like a normal game. Another thing, there are 19 roles and 18 players, not sure what that means, but I wanted to point it out.[/quote] It's quite possible tenn just messed up and one of the concerned citizens isn't in the game, because I would guess their only ability is to vote.[/quote] That would stink as that would mean there are only 14 towns folk now, not 15. If that is what happened, I wonder if TLM would clarify.

I think that will be the answer, if TLM clarifies then we know it's nothing but if he doesn't comment then obviously it's something.

[quote=MacEohaid]These players are awfully quiet. You new guys need to get more involved here. Don't be shy. C'mon in, the water is fine. 5 - robit 7 - pdbq 9 - hs0602 10 - calebdecker 14 - Rcomer727 15 - thepriceisright 17 - Hoodlum [/quote] Maybe they have jobs.......right?

[quote=KC321][spoiler]Okay Friends, I want to unpack some thoughts here. In the original post TLM calls Mafia the "bad guys" but calls town the "not bad guys" rather than the good guys. So, it sounds to me that their are a few neutrals in the "not bad guys/town" group. I know very little about Batman other than what the Christopher Nolan movies taught me, so I thought to myself, "If someone were a neutral who who it be?" I did some research on the Police officer roles and came up with the following: [spoiler][i]Angel Rojas is the police chief during the time of the Batman's first appearances in Gotham City. For Chief Rojas, The Batman is nothing less than a black eye to his police force. Believing there is no room for vigilante justice in Gotham, Rojas has made capturing the Dark Knight a top priority.[/i][/spoiler] [spoiler][i]Ellen Yindel was a Police Commissioner of Gotham City, who becomes obsessed with capturing Batman[/i][/spoiler] [spoiler][i]Ethan Bennett was a Gotham City Police Detective before he was driven insane by the Joker and transformed into Clayface.[/i][/spoiler] [spoiler]All this to say, their could be a member of the not bad guys that has a win clause to capture the Batman, or otherwise in Ethan Bennett's case[/spoiler] [/spoiler] [/quote] KC - this would make sense seeming that all Batman movies have bad cops to offset the "vigilante" theme.

[quote=MacEohaid]These players are awfully quiet. You new guys need to get more involved here. Don't be shy. C'mon in, the water is fine. 5 - robit 7 - pdbq 9 - hs0602 10 - calebdecker 14 - Rcomer727 15 - thepriceisright 17 - Hoodlum [/quote] Be careful what pool you get into. And this doesn't mean Macs pool is 1 way or the other.

[quote=ThickTalon][quote=MacEohaid]These players are awfully quiet. You new guys need to get more involved here. Don't be shy. C'mon in, the water is fine. 5 - robit 7 - pdbq 9 - hs0602 10 - calebdecker 14 - Rcomer727 15 - thepriceisright 17 - Hoodlum [/quote] Maybe they have jobs.......right? [/quote] I took a sick day! Villains don't have jobs.

I just find it funny that out of the blue 3 seem to show up after the Bell strikes 21:00. Work/life/or whatever. Don't try to bully your way into a situation cause you played a bad hand with your RIDDLE with the RIDDLER is a bad guy.

[quote=ThickTalon][quote=MacEohaid]These players are awfully quiet. You new guys need to get more involved here. Don't be shy. C'mon in, the water is fine. 5 - robit 7 - pdbq 9 - hs0602 10 - calebdecker 14 - Rcomer727 15 - thepriceisright 17 - Hoodlum [/quote] Maybe they have jobs.......right? [/quote] What's with the negative waves Moriarty, always with the negative waves. reference- Kelly's Heros, Donald Sutherland's role

[quote=2ofclubs][quote=MacEohaid]These players are awfully quiet. You new guys need to get more involved here. Don't be shy. C'mon in, the water is fine. 5 - robit 7 - pdbq 9 - hs0602 10 - calebdecker 14 - Rcomer727 15 - thepriceisright 17 - Hoodlum [/quote] Be careful what pool you get into. And this doesn't mean Macs pool is 1 way or the other.[/quote] I like that Clubs, now your playing nice.

My Man Mac. you are quite the heckler then jump on the defensive. Tell the Penguin to get his float ready for lift off.

[quote=ThickTalon][quote=MacEohaid]These players are awfully quiet. You new guys need to get more involved here. Don't be shy. C'mon in, the water is fine. 5 - robit 7 - pdbq 9 - hs0602 10 - calebdecker 14 - Rcomer727 15 - thepriceisright 17 - Hoodlum [/quote] Maybe they have jobs.......right? [/quote] Probably not, they are just afraid to participate because the big bad owl will gash their eyes out if thy joke around.

[quote=MacEohaid][quote=ThickTalon][quote=MacEohaid]These players are awfully quiet. You new guys need to get more involved here. Don't be shy. C'mon in, the water is fine. 5 - robit 7 - pdbq 9 - hs0602 10 - calebdecker 14 - Rcomer727 15 - thepriceisright 17 - Hoodlum [/quote] Maybe they have jobs.......right? [/quote] Probably not, they are just afraid to participate because the big bad owl will gash their eyes out if thy joke around.[/quote] This is very true.

Owls deal in absolutes. and Mac you remind me of a man on the run, keep your head on a swivel Riddler.