• 648 posts
  • Page 34 of 44
2ofclubs wrote:
WTF idfk
At least both town and scum know it's not me. Funny how pyg and notor both are active now. Just sayn'
WRKD4IT
2ofclubs is online.
Abs wrote:
How can 3 people be killed if only 1 mafia left?

So here is the list of players.

Players list

1 - bluegoetz
2 - rockbert - good guy - Commissioner James Gordon - killed night 3
3 - thicktalon - good guy - police chief Angel Rojas - killed night 3
4 - 2ofclubs
5 - robit - good guy - CC Tony - killed night 2
6 - elysium5 - good guy - officer Ellen Yi - killed night 4
7 - pdbq
8 - abs
9 - hs0602
10 - calebdecker - good guy - Alfred - lynched day 3
11 - pygmyhippo277
12 - notoriouspat - good guy - Batgirl - killed night 4
13 - KC321 - bad guy - Catwoman - killed night 2
14 - Rcomer727
15 - thepriceisright - bad guy - the Penguin - lynched day 4
16 - MacEohaid - good guy - Batman - killed night 2
17 - Hoodlum - good guy - Vicki Vale - killed night 4
18 - Ryomyr - bad guy - the Riddler - lynched day 2

So we have left:

2x Concerned Citizens who I know who has claimed this
1x Dr Leslie Thompkins
1x Joker (SCUM)
1x Police Officer
1x Robin
1x Aunt Harriet

People have claimed all these roles but only person who has not is Pdbq

So either PDBQ is Joker OR someone is lying

This is where we are and I am at a phase where I am not in anyway prepared to protest anyway now as everyone is a suspect as everyone I fully trusted 100% is now dead
Bluegoetz wrote:
Abs wrote:  Posted: Today, 21:51 
Post #499
How can 3 people be killed if only 1 mafia left?

one of many excellent questions
2ofclubs wrote:
Well hood got killed by friendly fire.
Joker killed 1/2x
Hmm a scum cop with own win clause???

Aunti wouldn't kill.
Doc wouldn't kill.
C-Citizen wouldn't kill
WRKD4IT
2ofclubs is online.
Abs wrote:
We need to also think about if this lynch is wrong, what is our next move in night phase?

2ofclubs wrote:
Chat 1 share my "chat" with 3. 3 &4 "share" with 2 &1. 4 share with 1. Then 5 it will be clear with all checks and balances in place.
WRKD4IT
2ofclubs is online.
Abs wrote:
 In another twist, I now have evidence that PDBQ is in fact our remaining unclaimed concerned citizen Pete,

#unlynch PDBQ

I know HS is also good, I have proof.

SO which one of you is lying I wonder.

Pygmy? Blue? Clubs? RC? It’s one of you and my current guess is Pygmy but could just be a dirty cop so which of the other 3 of you is Joker?
Abs wrote:
Let’s do this the easy way;

Let’s all see which roles you all claim and whosever sees their real role claimed by someone else then we know who our mole is:

We all now know I am Robin.

Abs - Robin
Clubs Claims - Dr Leslie Thompson
Pygmy Claims - Cop Ethan Bennett
PDBQ Claims - CC Peter
RComer Claims - CC Clark
Blue claims - CC Diana
HS0 claims - Aunt Harriet

There are 7 players left, 7 roles claimed above, all WITHOUT a JOKER

So we know they Joker is likely both Joker and one of the other players as there isn’t just a random role that isn’t assigned

So my view is, Ethan Bennett who was turned into Clayface BY THE JOKER has to be bad in some way

So for now my Lynch is #Lynch Pygmy

Clearly someone else if Pygmy is not both joker and clayface Is also lying but I don’t understand why there is an extra role

So anyone who doesn’t vote Pygmy for now is a key suspect but please also look at your name above and tell me if these roles do not match up?

Publicly shame in the forum, it’s the only way the true town win this lynch