Mafia Reindeer Games

[quote=Virtuosity98]Alex, I would never claim abominable snowman ^^ In fact, I claimed to three different players almost immediately on D1, before anyone else as far as I know, so I couldn't have forged the PM. AND no-one else has since claimed that name, which therefore means either I am who I claimed to those people, or I got a 1/9 chance on picking the reindeer that no-one else claimed (assuming all 9 weren't allocated), plus I somehow got the wording of the PM. Simply too impossible. So I must be who I claimed to be to those people.[/quote] Converted by now? :) @previous reply by you.

[quote=Virtuosity98][quote=AlexCheckMate]Feel free to let me know where this lynch on me is coming from :) Because I feel like you have just outed yourself as "non-town" @@Virtuosity98 [/quote] Go and reread [url=https://dominating12.com/tutorial/glossary]post 220[/url] if you want to know why this idea about V98 being non-town is not gaining traction :) [/quote] In my previous post I actually asked for you to explain me what caused the lynch on me. Please don't forget that part.

I'm only presenting facts. I don't think I'm muddying the water. That should tell you I'm a townie trying to solve the problem.

[quote=AlexCheckMate][quote=Virtuosity98][quote=AlexCheckMate]Feel free to let me know where this lynch on me is coming from :) Because I feel like you have just outed yourself as "non-town" @@Virtuosity98 [/quote] Go and reread [url=https://dominating12.com/tutorial/glossary]post 220[/url] if you want to know why this idea about V98 being non-town is not gaining traction :) [/quote] In my previous post I actually asked for you to explain me what caused the lynch on me. Please don't forget that part. [/quote] Because so far I don't have any reason to presume your innocence. Other players have presented favourable evidence at least once during the game.

[quote=Virtuosity98][quote=AlexCheckMate][quote=Virtuosity98][quote=AlexCheckMate]Feel free to let me know where this lynch on me is coming from :) Because I feel like you have just outed yourself as "non-town" @@Virtuosity98 [/quote] Go and reread [url=https://dominating12.com/tutorial/glossary]post 220[/url] if you want to know why this idea about V98 being non-town is not gaining traction :) [/quote] In my previous post I actually asked for you to explain me what caused the lynch on me. Please don't forget that part. [/quote] Because so far I don't have any reason to presume your innocence. Other players have presented favourable evidence at least once during the game. [/quote] Please do elaborate. What have others done which was positive for the game, when looking from towns perspective? What do you think about John, when looking at the movie? Bad guy?

Ok, I'll back up V98 with facts. The village distracter has told me whom he distracted. It was Alex. (He actually told me during the night faze). The fact that there is only one kill makes it a 6/7 chance of Alex being a killer. The only other thing that could of happened was that would mean Alex is innocent would be that mafia and neutral targetted the same person [b]Lynch AlexCheckmate[/b]

[quote=Madagascarter]Ok, I'll back up V98 with facts. The village distracter has told me whom he distracted. It was Alex. (He actually told me during the night faze). The fact that there is only one kill makes it a 6/7 chance of Alex being a killer. The only other thing that could of happened was that would mean Alex is innocent would be that mafia and neutral targetted the same person[/quote] The other nights, a badguy got shot. The previous night not. Maybe this helps?

I don't know the movie, I figured your claim was only half-serious haha ^^ are you sticking with John? Early name claims that would be difficult for mafia/neutrals to know were safe. Honest about night actions. Organising information to facilitate discussion. Being paranoid but opening up when presented with favourable evidence. Very townie things. Just some non-specific examples. But from you, I got no replies via PM, you jumped on a ridiculous assertion that I would claim a blatantly evil role name (a claim which has now been retracted by the source (Tennessee)), persisting with the claim despite the previous, and now claiming nothing more than John in plain view of everyone. I didn't say I was sure about you being mafia, it's just that so far I have had nothing from you to convince me you're innocent.

[quote=Virtuosity98]I don't know the movie, I figured your claim was only half-serious haha ^^ are you sticking with John? Early name claims that would be difficult for mafia/neutrals to know were safe. Honest about night actions. Organising information to facilitate discussion. Being paranoid but opening up when presented with favourable evidence. Very townie things. Just some non-specific examples. But from you, I got no replies via PM, you jumped on a ridiculous assertion that I would claim a blatantly evil role name (a claim which has now been retracted by the source (Tennessee)), persisting with the claim despite the previous, and now claiming nothing more than John in plain view of everyone. I didn't say I was sure about you being mafia, it's just that so far I have had nothing from you to convince me you're innocent.[/quote] (in response to https://dominating12.com/forums/5/off-topic/3514/mafia-reindeer-games/post/62509#post-62509)

I've been sticking with John from the start. There's been nothing irregular about what I've told anyone. You also know I try to abstain from talking in PM. I prefer broad daylight (forum).

[quote=AlexCheckMate]I've been sticking with John from the start. There's been nothing irregular about what I've told anyone. You also know I try to abstain from talking in PM. I prefer broad daylight (forum).[/quote] All I'm saying is there's no proof or even evidence of innocence. But for all other players there is at least something.

Who was the first person you claimed John to Alex?

[quote=AlexCheckMate] What do you think about John, when looking at the movie? Bad guy?[/quote] You haven’t claimed that you are John McClane from Die Hard yet. But you keep pointing out that he’s a good guy (besides thou shall not kill). You keep trying to say you are a good guy without actually claiming to be the one killing the bad guys. So, are you the one who shot the Grinch and the Mafia spy?

Yes I am Detective John McClane, who took down The Grinch and the mafia spy, and I have now discovered that R4W is someone who is non-village alligned. Can we start this party now please? :) @@Ready4war please tell me I'm spreading lies here.

[quote=AlexCheckMate]Yes I am Detective John McClane, who took down The Grinch and the mafia spy, and I have now discovered that R4W is someone who is non-village alligned. Can we start this party now please? :) @@Ready4war please tell me I'm spreading lies here.[/quote] Can you post Ely's inspection result? And what about the other nights?