You know, I think that instead of attempting to attain a comprehensive ranking system, it would be better to have categorical ranks. Right now, we could have skill points, rank, D12 for categories. But, in the future, more categories could account for different things. For instance, we could have capitals-based skill points vs. deathmatch based skill points. I can imagine a bunch of potential ranking systems.
This way, we get rid of the thought that any ranking system will be "comprehensive" or the "single-best." People are better at different things, and we could creatively construct categories to account for those things. Then, if someone consistently shows up at the top of each category, she will be considered a well-rounded and adaptive player.
You know, I think that instead of attempting to attain a comprehensive ranking system, it would be better to have categorical ranks. Right now, we could have skill points, rank, D12 for categories. But, in the future, more categories could account for different things. For instance, we could have capitals-based skill points vs. deathmatch based skill points. I can imagine a bunch of potential ranking systems.
This way, we get rid of the thought that any ranking system will be "comprehensive" or the "single-best." People are better at different things, and we could creatively construct categories to account for those things. Then, if someone consistently shows up at the top of each category, she will be considered a well-rounded and adaptive player.