Mafia D12 Style GAME THREAD

[quote=Rockbert][quote=elysium5][quote=anuorre]this on a tangent. but i think TLM might not be as squeaky clean as the state Tennessee gut feeling tells me ely is innocent though uncharacteristically chatty. TLM hasn't been very forthcoming and hiding things that only get picked up when confronted. AND - TLM has asked for special treatment after the last game :) I have a feeling we have a legit suspect here. TLM come clean - post your entire role[/quote] One more time, I am not uncharacteristically chatty. Others can attest to this in mafia games. I have not played the last two or three and the last couple before that I have been eliminated right away. I am very chatty, especially in PM's but I have only been part of one random PM here so I am probably chatting a little more in the forums.[/quote] I will say in Elysium's defense in terms of his play in past mafia games that yes, he is generally talkative. [/quote] Not that it really matters but thanks for verifying . I friggin' love these games and definitely do not coast when I play. The first game I played and was so lost I didn't think I would try it again but once I got the hang of it, I was and still am hooked very bad.

agree wholeheartedly. I have played in over 30 now I think and I love it!

Itchy for next game before active game is over. I have bad bad bad.

I'll let the next players who want to host go next, next, etc. but as soon as we have a gap, I will do the cannonball run again. Third time is the charm!

[quote=anuorre]The last game we had 3 mafias and ended quickly. I wouldn't be surprised if we have 4 or more. Keep your eyes peel. On my suspect list now, in order of suspiciousness (highest to lowest) 1. Tennesseelogman 2. Ryomyr 3. Anaxagore [/quote] I just re-read the entire forum thread again and though I don't like to draw hard conclusions without good evidence, other than my firm belief in this game that Thick is almost definitely town and both Cry and Jacob seem to be as well, I am tending to agree with this exactly as posted/listed. That leads me to also believe you are town as well, anuorre. For now.

It's night people. It's fine to just have a look out while you sleep. But are your enemies sleeping? I think not! Open coms and get your abilities submitted.

[quote=2ofclubs]It's night people. It's fine to just have a look out while you sleep. But are your enemies sleeping? I think not! Open coms and get your abilities submitted. [/quote] This sounds like more possible group chat opportunities and hopefully not from mafia. If you don't trust me yet, that's fine. At least get Thick involved, please, please, please!

Maybe Cry, Jacob, Rockbert and anourre now as well. They seem to be the most townie and most active.

Of course I would love to be part of one again as well so invite me too if you can but these players seem to be the best ones at this time to try and help gather some good intel and figure things out for town.

[quote=2ofclubs]Itchy for next game before active game is over. I have bad bad bad.[/quote] pretty obvious seeing as you are posting as much as a townie ;)

Radio silence and lights out. Charlie's is on the prowl.

Night 3 Update: [quote=2ofclubs]Officially! DAY 3 HAS ENDED IN FLURRY of &%$*#@ 3 for Ryomyr - [s]Thick Anourre, Jacob[/s] Ely Thick Jacob 2 for Crywolf - [s]Ely[/s], [s]Thick[/s], [s]Ryo[/s], KC, Blue 3 for Ely -TLM, Rock, Ryo 3 against lynch - Anuorre, Mac, Cry 0 Abastained - [s]Jacob[/s] 3 slept through it all. Mada, NPat, Anax With the flip flopping, abilities and clock applied. NO ONE WAS ELIMINATED All the manipulations caused each faction to basically shoot themselves in the foot. [b][size=16px]It is now NIGHT 3 phase 7[/size][/b][/quote] Updates: 1. Clubs confirms that TLM unlynch on Ely counted and lynch on Ryo counted (457/458) 2. Jacob observes that there may be a neutral faction, rather than just independents, based on Clubs' message (461) 3. Crywolf asks who he should investigate tonight (484) 4. Elysium invites investigations on him (485) 5. Rockbert requests town PM be called if possible, also isn't sure about Ryo (490) 6. Anuorre claims he got anonymous information saying that "Tennesselogman can tell if in a group Private Message (PM) what factions are in the group but not the player linked to it" and requests information from TLM. 7. Anuorre clarifies information came from moderator and he didn't use an ability to get it, calls out TLM. (497-503) 8. Rockbert floats theory that Anax, TLM, and Ryo are working together to con the town (507) 9. Ryo shows up for 1 post and calls out Thick and Ely for working together well right after mafia "found" each other. (Doesn't respond to any questions posed to him but willing to give benefit of the doubt that he missed some of the posts.) 10. Thick points out some players who didn't vote/participate - Mada, Anax. Also points out TLM isn't responding to allegations against him (523) Requested Information: - From Ryo: What is the list of 2 of 3 mafia you know and how do you know? What say you about a neutral faction? - From TLM: Why did you switch last minute when you said this: [quote=Tennesseelogman]i have a chat ban of such that does not allow me to copy paste from my role PM into the forum. i can only give the way i understand it. i have a limited number of opportunities to have the moderator give me the odds of success in a battle. i can choose balanced dice or original dice and name the defender - i then am told the odds of that player being mafia, town, or neutral. ely came up 67% mafia. this sounds fishy i know but as i said - i will bet my life on it. if i am wrong = kill me. if i am right protect me and give me another phase to provide info. past my bedtime (as some of you know) i will be up by 6am to check things briefly and then out most of the day but back on around 3-4 pm[/quote] If you were willing to bet your life on Ely, why'd you switch?

Possible suspicious groupings: 1. Ryo, Anax, TLM - Voted Crywolf after he shared pretty decent information on his ability. 2. Thick and Ely - Very loud in forum chat, working together perhaps suspiciously well? 3. Bluegoetz, NotoriousPat - Have been really quiet in forum chat - potential neutral? My top suspects: (in this order) 1. Ryo - seems obvious because he's neutral at best with a WC involving killing Town. Also seems like he has a faction per his WC 2. TLM - really weird vote switch from Ely to Crywolf... didn't give a reason for it or defend his actions 3. KC321 - Has been quite antagonistic towards me while not really helping town himself 4. Bluegoetz - voted Crywolf as well, has been really checked out in the forum chat 5. Elysium - If TLM is good, then Ely is 67% mafia per TLM's alleged ability Townies I trust: (in this order) 1. Rockbert - I feel like he's the only other confirmed town guy who's been really active in the forum 2. Thick - Seems like the better option of the Thick/Ely duo - doesn't fully trust Ely which I think is smart. Has been targeting Ryo which I agree with. 3. Crywolf - Gave solid info from Clubs PM, not sure why everyone is on him... 4. Anuorre - Out of most of the drama but bringing up good points. Would like him to stay engaged 5. Anax - willing to believe he might have been silenced somehow, seemed solid before - TLM could be confirming him as town to build his own resume. However, his town confirmation is a bit sketchy due to the TLM thing

[quote]If you were willing to bet your life on Ely, why'd you switch?[/quote] ely knows why - my vote is an anti-vote. i revealed this in our PM (others knew) i am still 67% convinced that ely is mafia therefore i tried to get a lynch vote started on him but knew that my vote would cancel someone else's therefore = my last minute vote switch. go ahead and let ely deny he knew it before anyone else call him on it. gone again today to work for 7 hrs. i can not do this on my phone (too old)

[quote=Tennesseelogman][quote]If you were willing to bet your life on Ely, why'd you switch?[/quote] ely knows why - my vote is an anti-vote. i revealed this in our PM (others knew) i am still 67% convinced that ely is mafia therefore i tried to get a lynch vote started on him but knew that my vote would cancel someone else's therefore = my last minute vote switch. go ahead and let ely deny he knew it before anyone else call him on it. gone again today to work for 7 hrs. i can not do this on my phone (too old)[/quote] Very interesting. Ely what say you?