$$$$$$$$$$$$$
  • 326 posts
  • Page 12 of 22
dough_boy wrote:
Spoiler (click to show)

So Hood made a mistake and said there was only one attack on me.

Jimi initially said he was going to transport Syg and myself. We decided to change and I suggested Syg and Ely OR durandalblue. He said he made the change as suggested (but never told me who). Because hood confirmed Jimi changed his targets around I can only assume it was Syg and either of those other two.

Syg was on alert, so Jimi died.

Skarni was going to investigate Kyla, but in the end looks like he switched to Syg (which killed him).

dwcalvert was killed by serial killer.

Riskk was protecting someone (I never 100% verified they were bodyguard) and never told me who it was, and I never gave them suggestions on whom to protect. When being transported all actions "against" someone are swapped to the other person. So if Riskk was protecting say Ely, that protection would then swap to Syg and the body guard would die.

Double Claim for Veteran (click to show)

So we know the Sk didn't target me. We know I wasn't tied to the transport. Either the Vig shot at me or the Godfather targeted me again correct? Anaxagore has claimed to also be attacked. So that would be one of these targeting me, and the other targeting Anaxagore?

Oh...and my apologies Syg...
Hoodlum wrote:
i have to come to doughboys defense with the double attack.. i did tell doughboy he was attacked twice accidentally. it's my bedtime..
zzzzz.
Anaxagore wrote:
Hoodlum, Can we know if the Bodyguard was killed protecting someone or targeted? "The Bodyguard didn't get the honourable death he wanted. " Does this mean he died not protecting anyone?

Thanks
Sygmassacre wrote:
#Unlynch paulcha
We know hes mafia, jester or SK. Now we need to decide which one. If hes mafia then the Godfather wouldnt put himself out there as a counter claim. After all he cant die at night but can be lynched so they wont let him counter claim and be proven wrong. So now we have Consig, Jester or SK. There are 3 claims for escort and only one can be true, if any. At least 2 of those are bad and we need the names. They should be the targets of our lynch
A Harmonic Generator Intermodulator
 Σ
Kyla wrote:
01. Jimi //transporter
02. Dough_boy //publicly claimed survivor
03. Huskers01 //
04. Vicious //
05. Skarni //
06. Kyla //town
07. Madagascarter //framer
08. Sygmassacre //publicly claimed veteran
09. Elysium5 //publicly claimed escort
10. Henris_1 //lookout
11. dwcalvert //blackmailer
12. sbsportz5
13. jimmy1066 //publicly claimed vig
14. paulcha //
15. Riskk //bodyguard
16. Anaxagore //
17. DurandalBlue //

I think this is right
dough_boy wrote:
The Investigator felt he was on to something, but swithced his target later that day. A gut feeling made him change his mind and his target changed. But so did the targets location. Instead, there that crazy old Veteran he knew about. Too late to run, he was on high alert. The Investigator died. Skarni was the Investigator

Wait...so my last suggestion was that Skarni shouldn't investigate Kyla but instead one of the others (Jimi, huskers01, Vicious, dwcalvert, elysium5). I never heard back if he changed or not. But the message above indicates he did switch from Kyla to someone else ("but swithced his target later that day" ). Well...it also indicates that his new targets location changed ("But so did the targets location" ) which means they were transported. I told him Jimi claimed transporter so this means skarni would have chosen elysium5 most likely. This means that his investigation would have switched to Syg and that is how skarni died.

So now we know how so many died...Jimi transported the veteran (Syg). Skarni investigated elysium5 which changed to Syg and died. Riskk protected elysium5 which changed to Syg and died.

We know that the SK took out dw (thanks!).

Elysium5 visited Kyla the first night but she didn't die so that means he has a night action.

That would only leave two possible attackers left correct? One is the Vig and one is the Godfather.

We also know that paulcha is bad...but the question is which bad. Serial Killer bad, or mafia bad (Godfather).

I received the following message from someone:

• paulcha said:
07 Oct 2017, 12:23
Just one other question, sorry if the info is provided, and I bother you with my questions.
How does the doctor choose who he wants to protect. Does he choose the role he wants to protect or just a name?
Could he be protecting me or a mafia person for instance?

That is a weird way to phrase it. Knowing he is bad, but not claiming to be mafia might mean that paulcha is the Serial Killer.

We know that the Serial Killer has killed every night. Well, three people have claimed to be Escort. Kyla, Ely and durandalblue. Kylas message to me is that she on the first night Escorted paulcha (which if they are the SK would means she would be killed). On top of this she told me that she was going to Escort Ely last night (and actually just confirmed it). If this happened then she would have died too because it would have switched to Syg. So I believe this makes durandalblue the true escort and makes Kyla the Godfather or Consigliere. But why would Kyla be the first to lynch mad (who was always blaming me and not Kyla)? Because the mafia decided that it was better off sacrificing one of their own to keep another in the loop and the framer would only be successful if they framed the same person that the sheriff looked at. It could also be that Kyla isn't the Godfather and is instead the Consigliere, but I believe that unless she is the Jester she is mafia.

All of this being said I believe we are looking at

Godfather/Consigliere - Kyla
Serial Killer - Paulcha

We cannot kill the Serial Killer at night so I would say lynch paulcha today.

Tonight I would say that the Vig (who likely only has one bullet left) would shoot Kyla.

The only caveat to all of this is the Jester (who wants to be lynched). I would think that they would be trying to get lynched, but the only other two suspects are huskers01 and vicious...both of which haven't really provided anything to be "self incriminating". So there is a chance that Kyla or Paulcha could be the jester. elysium couldn't be the jester because there isn't any night actions and he did a night action against kyla (Sheriffs report from night one), which brings up an interesting point...if Ely is mafia why would he visit another Mafia member. Then this hit me "*The Jester is a town detection immune role. False information will be given to investigative roles (Sheriff, Lookout, Investigator)." So could the false information be that Ely visited Kyla (because the Lookout was watching Kyla)? If so (since why would a mafia visit a mafia) I believe that elysium is actually the jester (since he said he knew who the jester was).

This would only leave two roles left on my board (assuming I am accurate). The jailer and the consigliere and huskers01 and vicious. Jimmy says he knows who the jailer is and that he wants to stay hidden. So if the jailer comes forward we might have wrapped this up.
dough_boy wrote:
Sheriff - vicious/sbsportz5/anaxagore
Investigator - Skarni
Lookout - Henris_01
Veteran - Sygmassacre
Vigilante - jimmy1066
Bodyguard - Riskk
Doctor - vicious/sbsportz5/anaxagore
Escort - DurdandalBlue
Transporter - Jimi
Jailer - vicious/sbsportz5/anaxagore
Godfather - kyla/huskers01
Framer - Madagascarter
Consigliere - kyla/huskers01
Blackmailer - dwcalvert
Survivor - dough_boy
Jester - elysium5
Serial Killer - paulcha

Bold are "vetted". 
Bold/Striked are vetted dead.
Italics are likely.
Kyla wrote:
Yes so it's impossible for paulcha to be serial killer, I would also like to point out that I was jailed last night so I couldn't actually do my night action, I am the escort
dough_boy wrote:
Kyla
Yes so it's impossible for paulcha to be serial killer, I would also like to point out that I was jailed last night so I couldn't actually do my night action, I am the escort
Not really. You could have been the consiglieri on the first night (which wouldn't kill you) but an escort would kill you. Which would then make you the Consiglieri and Huskers01 the Godfather.
Kyla wrote:
Also, are you saying that the jester visted me? Seems you're confused dough
Anaxagore wrote:
hold on everyone: we are only 6 town left, so making a mistake today would be the end probably.

before making any conclusion about paulcha or sygamassacre.
paulcha told me he was blackmailed and cannot talk today.
I am not sure at all sygamassacre is the real veteran and I don't like dough changed his mind that fast concerning sygamassagre.
Though I am not making conclusion yet about who the real veteran is for now.

> I want to hear what jimmy has to say about what happenned last night.
he tried to kill me (if he is the real vig), and i want to know why. Did someone told him to do so?
Someone manipulated many people last turn, that's how the Veteran killed 2 TOWN. I don't believe it is a coincidence.

Also mafia killed the bodyguard, so if dough received a message saying he was attack, there can only be one explanation:
the bodyguard was protecting dough. therefore dough could have received the message he was attacked and the bodyguard killed.

By the way, dough, why would you say you are not sure i am doctor?

My messages with Hoodlum were not a sufficient proof?

Spoiler (click to show)
]

hope everyone trust me now and i am waiting for other people to talk more about what they think!