Mafia D12 Style GAME THREAD

Hey Mafia, The way TLM's WC reads is he can still win if I die, keep your shots to yourself

Thick, you are misreading my post. I am not advocating for waiting I am just saying I don't know the definitive answer. If the town wishes to reveal I will comply with town. As I said before that though, we have some very good mafia disguised among us.

Agree on the disguises.

Pros to sharing is that we might find some unwilling to share or with questionable answers that we can oust as mafia. Cons are that mafia will know who to kill with powerful abilities.

This is not a solo decision to make, but I vote in favor.

Is there anyone who can start a pm chat?

75% through phase

My guess is no player can start a PM chat now that the 2 Neutrals with that ability are gone.

Unfortunately, I think that if there was a townie who could it would be done by now. Looks like Clubs reserved PM creation for the neutrals and mafia only.

Thick, it might be worth taking a shot tonight at one of the inactives. If they want to live they should give us something in the forum to prove their innocence by phase end.

Medics should know what to do. I don't want to say too much because I don't want to clue in the mafia so I'm leaving this vaugue. Townies with block and save abilities have done amazing so far as the mafia haven't killed anyone yet.

Who should we have Anax and Cry investigate tonight?

As for ability sharing, I'll give the hint that my ability has been useless so far which is fortunate. Also, Clubs wants to grow up to be TLM. I'm not sure how useful my ability will be down the road but I will share if we vote in favor of sharing abilities.

My town trust tier list:

Tier 1:
1. Jacob
2. ThickTalon - Verified by Anax, successfully shut down TLM
3. Rockbert - Has been helpful although no verification
4. Mac - Verified by Crywolf, shared Role PM which matched investigation

Tier 2:
5. Crywolf - Claims investigator, outed TLM
6. Mada - No verification
7. Anax - Claims investigator and shared a lot, but has not been very active and vouched for Bluegoetz, who has a strange ability


Tier 3:
8. Bluegoetz
9. Anuorre
10. KC321
11. NPat

Dead:
Ely - Mafia
Ryomyr - Neutral
TLM - Neutral

Hit the wrong button, was still in the middle of typing that. Here's the final:

My town trust tier list:

Tier 1:
1. Jacob
2. ThickTalon - Verified by Anax, successfully shut down TLM
3. Rockbert - Has been helpful although no verification
4. Mac - Verified by Crywolf, shared Role PM which matched investigation

Tier 2:
5. Crywolf - Claims investigator, outed TLM, has shared PM's pretty openly.
6. Mada - No verification but has shared useful information and was active in D1 Red Card PM where he formed plans to verify win conditions.
7. Anax - Claims investigator and shared a lot, but has not been very active and vouched for Bluegoetz, who has a strange ability


Tier 3:
8. Bluegoetz - Anax verified but has strange ability to mess with players' actions - claims he hasn't used it but on TLM
9. Anuorre - No verification, no ability or PM sharing to my knowledge.
10. KC321 - Lynch votes have been all over the place, following Thick without providing much, kind of like what Ely did.
11. NPat - Claims blocking ability with turning off Wi-Fi which he used against me. Hasn't shared or done much.

Dead:
Ely - Mafia
Ryomyr - Neutral
TLM - Neutral

Please give me your thoughts on why you or other players should be higher/lower.

I provide my total PM... post 899 and Rock gets "helpful" in your description. I just got Tier envy, thats all!...

Have you been in any PMs Jacob? Maybe forum posts are lean for me, but not in PMs

Already shared mine so I guess I'll kick it off?

I love the smell of Napalm in the morning.
https://youtu.be/_eMK5MZTpuU
But for who? Still up for grabs.