Mafia D12 Style GAME THREAD

[quote=MacEohaid][quote=Tennesseelogman]i have a chat ban of such that does not allow me to copy paste from my role PM into the forum. i can only give the way i understand it. i have a limited number of opportunities to have the moderator give me the odds of success in a battle. i can choose balanced dice or original dice and name the defender - i then am told the odds of that player being mafia, town, or neutral. ely came up 67% mafia. this sounds fishy i know but as i said - i will bet my life on it. if i am wrong = kill me. if i am right protect me and give me another phase to provide info. past my bedtime (as some of you know) i will be up by 6am to check things briefly and then out most of the day but back on around 3-4 pm[/quote] I was just rereading past posts and it appears that you used your ability on Ely and he came up suspect (67%). Why are you saying that there were two mafia in our chat and throw suspicion on me (and Thick) in the process, as if one other of us had to be mafia along with Ely. I'm not suspicious of you but I don't see why you think I or Thick are mafia. Do you have another ability that shows exactly how many are mafia in a PM? Whoever has investigative ability can check me out and will find the following on me: 2ofclubs said: 21 Nov 2023, 16:29 5. MacEohaid Role: Tan - Town Free Account aka NewBee w ???????? ?????? Abilities: 1. You have a night phase ?????? ????? ????. 2. You have night vision and ??? ???????? ???? ????????. WC: Your faction wins when all Mafia are killed - ????????????????????????.[/quote] This lines up with Crywolf's investigation. Unless Mac and Cry are in together which I don't think makes sense but I guess is possible?

I like your reasoning Jacob and it leaves me conflicted.

[quote=Madagascarter]I like your reasoning Jacob and it leaves me conflicted.[/quote] I'm conflicted right there with you. Let's not let TLM turn us against each other just yet. We can hopefully get some more info tonight.

If you all are Investigating the right person you should get the results.

[quote=ThickTalon]If you all are Investigating the right person you should get the results. [/quote] What do you mean?

[quote=KC321][quote=Madagascarter]Wait, there was a mafia in our first group with TLM, Jacob & me? I am going to vote for Jacob then. Mainly cause I don’t think it would be a good play for mafia to waste a day kill on their own people so early no matter the shenanigans. It’s a shame cause Jacob has been a good player and to this point he was last on my suspicion lists. But if TLM is telling the truth, which I’m inclined to believe he is, I’ve got to vote for Jacob.[/quote] Wow, if Jacob is mafia, he’s the best actor since Tom Cruise [/quote] I think you mean Kevin Bacon. haha. Depends on who is the mafia. I can see the seasoned vets making that move if they knew they would inherit some of Elysium's abilities. Not saying it's likely. But it is possible. I have a feeling we have some heavies playing the mafia in this game.

i am the one that has provided the most info and made a mafia kill single handed. thick keeps demanding full role PMs. where is his. what has he done or provided to town except confusion. because of me (in large part) no town has died = he should be happy about that - but - no. thick is 50/50 mafia = if we lynch him and he flips town = all we have lost is a player playing oddly and then we get mac. if he flips town = then we have a known mafia in mac. those of you who know me, know that i play a very logical game (i am terrible at figuring out clubs babbling clues) = this is the logical course of action. if both flip town i will quit the game. the odds of lynching a mafia without this info is only 1 out of 4 or 5 (depending on how many there are) which is what often times happens. [b]give us your full role pm thick[/b] - now that you've had several to copy from. we have the same odds of getting a mafia if we lynch thick, mac, mada, or jacob = all 50/50 and it gives us so much info

[quote]thick is 50/50 mafia = if we lynch him and he flips town = all we have lost is a player playing oddly and then we get mac. if he flips town = then we have a known mafia in mac.[/quote] should read thick is 50/50 mafia = if we lynch him and he flips town = all we have lost is a player playing oddly and then we get mac. if he flips [b]mafia [/b]= then we have a known [b]town[/b] in mac.

[quote=Tennesseelogman]i am the one that has provided the most info and made a mafia kill single handed. thick keeps demanding full role PMs. where is his. what has he done or provided to town except confusion. because of me (in large part) no town has died = he should be happy about that - but - no. thick is 50/50 mafia = if we lynch him and he flips town = all we have lost is a player playing oddly and then we get mac. if he flips town = then we have a known mafia in mac. those of you who know me, know that i play a very logical game (i am terrible at figuring out clubs babbling clues) = this is the logical course of action. if both flip town i will quit the game. the odds of lynching a mafia without this info is only 1 out of 4 or 5 (depending on how many there are) which is what often times happens. [b]give us your full role pm thick[/b] - now that you've had several to copy from. we have the same odds of getting a mafia if we lynch thick, mac, mada, or jacob = all 50/50 and it gives us so much info[/quote] I tend to agree here, but I'm happy to hear other ideas

[quote=Jacob24][quote=KC321Wow, if Jacob is mafia, he’s the best actor since Tom Cruise [/quote] Almost makes me wish I was mafia for that compliment :)[/quote] Am I playing checkers while Jacob is playing chess?

[quote=Tennesseelogman]i am the one that has provided the most info and made a mafia kill single handed. thick keeps demanding full role PMs. where is his. what has he done or provided to town except confusion. because of me (in large part) no town has died = he should be happy about that - but - no. thick is 50/50 mafia = if we lynch him and he flips town = all we have lost is a player playing oddly and then we get mac. if he flips town = then we have a known mafia in mac. those of you who know me, know that i play a very logical game (i am terrible at figuring out clubs babbling clues) = this is the logical course of action. if both flip town i will quit the game. the odds of lynching a mafia without this info is only 1 out of 4 or 5 (depending on how many there are) which is what often times happens. [b]give us your full role pm thick[/b] - now that you've had several to copy from. we have the same odds of getting a mafia if we lynch thick, mac, mada, or jacob = all 50/50 and it gives us so much info[/quote] No need for me to rush for your request TLM. Yes you do play very logical, yes you know EVERYONE's tendencies because you moderate 60% of our games. As you know I also am honest to a fault in these games. I know if you are Mafia you are extremely dangerous. I know for a fact you are not the dominator which means you are another Neutral (same abilities as RYO from the looks of it) or Mafia pulling the Godfather puppet strings on the bandwagon players you know so well. again , YOU ARE NOT THE DOMINATOR.

[quote=KC321][quote=Tennesseelogman]i am the one that has provided the most info and made a mafia kill single handed. thick keeps demanding full role PMs. where is his. what has he done or provided to town except confusion. because of me (in large part) no town has died = he should be happy about that - but - no. thick is 50/50 mafia = if we lynch him and he flips town = all we have lost is a player playing oddly and then we get mac. if he flips town = then we have a known mafia in mac. those of you who know me, know that i play a very logical game (i am terrible at figuring out clubs babbling clues) = this is the logical course of action. if both flip town i will quit the game. the odds of lynching a mafia without this info is only 1 out of 4 or 5 (depending on how many there are) which is what often times happens. [b]give us your full role pm thick[/b] - now that you've had several to copy from. we have the same odds of getting a mafia if we lynch thick, mac, mada, or jacob = all 50/50 and it gives us so much info[/quote] I tend to agree here, but I'm happy to hear other ideas [/quote] [b]@KC[/b] - you agree with what? That I am Mafia or that TLM is doing the work for you. Be your own town and use your ability for some good (I have no idea what that ability is since you have been absent from this game) [b]@TLM[/b] - you said earlier in the game that you were "restricted with chat" care to share how? why was it lifted? Also you have given the best information because you created 2 of the 4 chats and had the most information at hand. the rest of us are playing on an unlevel playing field with the PM restrictions. NOT TO MENTION you MAfia chat (allegedly)

Thick, you know for a fact TLM is not a town dominator? Could he potentially be the Neutral Dominator? In TLM's role PM reveal he claimed to have an ability that could affect Neutral and Town Dominators. Ryo had very similar abilities to what TLM is claiming but was [b]not[/b] the neutral dominator, rather his role was "Dice". This makes me think TLM could be a neutral as well? He never really went after Ryo to my knowledge, possible they were working together. I keep coming back to the #Lynch Kill Vote. It doesn't seem like a town ability to me but maybe it's just because I'm new?

Also, how do you know he's not town dominator?

[quote=Jacob24]Thick, you know for a fact TLM is not a town dominator? Could he potentially be the Neutral Dominator? In TLM's role PM reveal he claimed to have an ability that could affect Neutral and Town Dominators. Ryo had very similar abilities to what TLM is claiming but was [b]not[/b] the neutral dominator, rather his role was "Dice". This makes me think TLM could be a neutral as well? He never really went after Ryo to my knowledge, possible they were working together. I keep coming back to the #Lynch Kill Vote. It doesn't seem like a town ability to me but maybe it's just because I'm new?[/quote] He could be the Neutral Dominator, just not the Town. Like I said earlier i highly doubt Clubs would not give the Town dominator a lesser ability set than the Mafia Dominator.