Mafia Game Thread
  • 911 posts
  • Page 47 of 61
MacEohaid wrote:
1. @Tennesseelogman Tomato
2. @Rockbert
3. @KC321
4. @notoriouspat
5. @Rcomer727 Gardener
6. @ThickTalon
7. @jkl3699 Tomato
8. @2ofclubs.
9. @Ryomyr. Tomato
10. @Hoodlum Gardener
11. @MacEohaid
12. @pygmyhippo277
13. @Abs
14. @Anaxagore
15. @DreamStreet (Tenn 2) Tomato
16. @BadKarma

There are only 10 left without a slug dead.
We are getting slaughtered: 4 dead tomatoes and 2 gardeners.
It's do or die time tomatoes. 
Here's my take at this point of the game:

Slugs: Abs, 2oC, Notorius and BadKarma
Tomatoes: Thick, Pygmy, Rock, Anax and Mac
Unsure: KC
BadKarma wrote:
MacEohaid
1. @Tennesseelogman Tomato
2. @Rockbert
3. @KC321
4. @notoriouspat
5. @Rcomer727 Gardener
6. @ThickTalon
7. @jkl3699 Tomato
8. @2ofclubs.
9. @Ryomyr. Tomato
10. @Hoodlum Gardener
11. @MacEohaid
12. @pygmyhippo277
13. @Abs
14. @Anaxagore
15. @DreamStreet (Tenn 2) Tomato
16. @BadKarma

There are only 10 left without a slug dead.
We are getting slaughtered: 4 dead tomatoes and 2 gardeners.
It's do or die time tomatoes. 
Here's my take at this point of the game:

Slugs: Abs, 2oC, Notorius and BadKarma
Tomatoes: Thick, Pygmy, Rock, Anax and Mac
Unsure: KC

Check your messages... You're wrong about me - but hey - Salt me today instead and find out!



Message: Savage Garden Role PM
From: elysium5
To: BadKarma
elysium5 said:
07 Aug 2022, 05:59
You are a Tomato Plant.

Day Action
You can vote to #Salt Players Name each day phase.

Night Action
You have no night action.

Win Clause: You win if all the Slugs die before they kill the Tomato Plants.
elysium5 said:
16 Aug 2022, 15:57
I moved your question to this thread. It's is too easy to lose direct Role PM questions and information by using or creating separate threads for those.

BadKarma said:
16 Aug 2022, 14:15
is is ok for me to quote an IM in the forum?

I have no rules about copy and pasting.
BadKarma said:
16 Aug 2022, 16:01
ok - great - I had gotten that response from others and went ahead assuming you'd verify once you got online.
elysium5 said:
16 Aug 2022, 16:24
All good. There are other games where it is not allowed but I don't do it that way because I also post all the roles in the beginning so as not to make it possible for someone to find hidden flaws or mistakes in role claims to use against others. I also send out all roles at the same time so the time stamps are usually within the minute and I send every role out randomly so there is no particular order sequence for assigned roles that can be inferred using the timestamps.

Also, I use a random number generator to assign roles. The assignments are random always. Doesn't matter if the players are new or experienced or how 'important' a role might be. It is always random selection for me.

I also don't try to balance a game behind the scenes. If one group gets lucky, they get lucky. If they figure something out and get a good move early, good for them. It is all part of the game.

On a side note, this post where I brought Tenn back:
https://dominating12.com/forums/5/off-topic/3781/savage-garden/post/82405#post-82405

I did not do this to 'balance' the game or because the role was 'importan't or not or for any other reasons other than it was early in the game, a player wasn't able to continue and another active player was available to take over.

This is not something I usually do because there is usually some sort of message exchange that could hurt/help a specific team but this case was special as there were no compromising PM's or any other issues that would make this a bad scenario one way or the other so I decided to offer Tenn a chance to play for the other player.

Buen Camino!
2ofclubs wrote:
BadKarma
#Unsalt Abs
#Salt BadKarma

Signing off
BadKarma
#Unsalt Abs
#Salt BadKarma

Signing off

Wow I don't think the martyr will fly LoL
WRKD4IT
2ofclubs wrote:
MacEohaid
I meant that Tenn validated pygmy. And Thick btw.
How?
RC didn't clear Thick. I am not accusing just stating the facts inspite of smoke and mirrors.
WRKD4IT
Abs wrote:
Lol Bad Karma! You should have not salted yourself on the forum! Your making it obvious now you are a slug! Just vote me and keep under the radar!
Abs wrote:
Oh S*** that was meant to be a PM not on the forum hahaha!

Sorry BK, well I think the Tomatoes just got a helping hand there! Sorry slugs!
BadKarma wrote:
Abs
Oh S*** that was meant to be a PM not on the forum hahaha!

Sorry BK, well I think the Tomatoes just got a helping hand there! Sorry slugs!

Gee Abs, I thought I was the rookie. Everyone will definitely believe you meant to send that by PM. What a clever idea you had there.
Buen Camino!
BadKarma wrote:
Logged back on after taking a much needed break:

Seriously, if you want to find out if I’m tomato or if, as a first time player I figured out I could edit the role PM, convince a bunch of players im a tomato and I’m really a slug like our slimy co-player Abs is…And If you’re that confident that I’m really that good, enough to risk the number of tomatoes left… there is only one way to find out!
Buen Camino!
pygmyhippo277 wrote:
Bad is starting to look a bit slimy... not very good, I think KARMA is gonna come back to bite him :roll:
Eat my dust.
BadKarma wrote:
pygmyhippo277
Bad is starting to look a bit slimy... not very good, I think KARMA is gonna come back to bite him :roll:
so, slimy means meeting a challenge head on and logically talking it through? Roger that.

And your words of wisdom would be to what exactly? how should one conduct themselves when the inevitable spotlight lands upon them? I figured I'd give the old fashioned truth a try -
look back... ask around to folks who've spoken to me (you certainly haven't) - if asked I'm straight up and honest and blunt.
Buen Camino!
ThickTalon wrote:
So by this standard. ABS IS ELIMINATED TODAY.

Karma is now suspect #2 but can stick around for a round. Any of you other slugs want to 'slip' up?
BadKarma wrote:
ThickTalon
So by this standard. ABS IS ELIMINATED TODAY.

Karma is now suspect #2 but can stick around for a round. Any of you other slugs want to 'slip' up?

Thick- you realize there are those who have had you on the slug list from the beginning - the ONLY thing that got some folks backed off is you were working with TLM. But some also think that was a really smart move from a slug perspective.

100% tomato here - I got nothing to hide.
Buen Camino!