Mafia Game Thread
  • 911 posts
  • Page 21 of 61
Tennesseelogman wrote:
gg hood - hood had revealed to me that he was the gardener - not because he had inspected me, but because he knew like most of you do that everything i have said and done has been for a town win. he did inspect jkl and found him a tomato plant. i can not prove i am tomato but i can prove hood trusted me.  however, this is not like the hoodtown game where we can all send jkl our roles due to many roles being the same. jkl was willing to be the mouthpiece for hood and is likely willing to do the same for the other gardener. the only info now that is relevant is who did the other gardener inspect night 1 .
we knew a town was going to get killed last night. so let's not panic and start lynching just because it was the gardener. if the other gardener will contact me, we will have confirmed him, jkl, hopefully his night 1 target, and 1 other i am fairly certain on = 4 known town. 6 unknown town, 4 slugs. a salt vote would now still be more likely to hit a tomato if we go just on hunches. so at this point my votes stays
# no salt
Live long and prosper
Tennesseelogman is online.
BadKarma wrote:
Ah ryomyr, your timing is perfect. And aligns nicely with what I was about to post…

In complete transparency so all players - lush tomatoes and slimy slugs - can discuss, defend, accuse - here is my current running list of who I believe to be aligned where. The “unsure” list either haven’t said much or there hasn’t been a data point to push my opinion one direction or the other.

Town= 2ofClubs, Ten, BadKarma, Rockbert, pygmyhippo277
Slugs= JKL, ThickTalon, Ryomyr, Abs
Unsure  : Anaxgore, KC321, notoriouspat, MacEohaid, Rcomer727,
Dead:Dreamstreet, hoodlum
Buen Camino!
BadKarma wrote:
I was writing that as Tenn was posting. I may be convinced to move JKL to the “unsure” list. But will be tough to be convinced that easily that he’s full trust worthy tomato
Buen Camino!
jkl3699 wrote:
Tennesseelogman
gg hood - hood had revealed to me that he was the gardener - not because he had inspected me, but because he knew like most of you do that everything i have said and done has been for a town win. he did inspect jkl and found him a tomato plant. i can not prove i am tomato but i can prove hood trusted me.  however, this is not like the hoodtown game where we can all send jkl our roles due to many roles being the same. jkl was willing to be the mouthpiece for hood and is likely willing to do the same for the other gardener. the only info now that is relevant is who did the other gardener inspect night 1 .
we knew a town was going to get killed last night. so let's not panic and start lynching just because it was the gardener. if the other gardener will contact me, we will have confirmed him, jkl, hopefully his night 1 target, and 1 other i am fairly certain on = 4 known town. 6 unknown town, 4 slugs. a salt vote would now still be more likely to hit a tomato if we go just on hunches. so at this point my votes stays
# no salt
Completely agree. #no salt
Tennesseelogman wrote:
as you can see from the forum posts - hood and i were online at the same time - and we were chatting. that's when he confided in me. i confirmed he was the afternoon gardener so i put a prover in the forum in case something like this happened.
Tennesseelogman wrote:  Posted: Today, 02:41 
Post #281
well i am not going to wait until after 12pm for the results - good night - hope i am alive in the morning to chat
after 12pm does not mean after midnight but = afternoon as in afternoon gardener
Live long and prosper
Tennesseelogman is online.
jkl3699 wrote:
jkl3699 said:
11 Aug 2022, 15:07
Hm okay, I guess we're all in limbo haha
Hoodlum said:
12 Aug 2022, 02:34
i decided to let TLM know that i am gardener. and that u were inspected and cleared as a tomato plant.
hope it's not a mistake. i think we might need some help, to get players off your back. TLM maintains he is the same role, and will take a bullet again.
Hoodlum said:
12 Aug 2022, 02:35
Tennesseelogman
cmon ely it has been 38.5 hours since you got the inspection request - what gives?

he's making moves. lol
jkl3699 said:
12 Aug 2022, 03:01
He asked me if you're afternoon or morning gardener
Hoodlum said:
12 Aug 2022, 03:07
im afternoon gardener
Ryomyr wrote:
BadKarma
Ah ryomyr, your timing is perfect. And aligns nicely with what I was about to post…

In complete transparency so all players - lush tomatoes and slimy slugs - can discuss, defend, accuse - here is my current running list of who I believe to be aligned where. The “unsure” list either haven’t said much or there hasn’t been a data point to push my opinion one direction or the other.

Town= 2ofClubs, Ten, BadKarma, Rockbert, pygmyhippo277
Slugs= JKL, ThickTalon, Ryomyr, Abs
Unsure  : Anaxgore, KC321, notoriouspat, MacEohaid, Rcomer727,
Dead:Dreamstreet, hoodlum

Maybe this is a mistake on your part, or a diversion. 

Call me Gilbert. Tomatoes are my game. 

...
Ryomyr wrote:
I will be gone for a long time today. 

TOWN, please PM me if Pygmy is not the way to go.
...
Abs wrote:
Gg Hood! This is not good for town now, I have a feeling JKL is a slug and i Am still nervous about Ten’s role he has come back as.

Has anyone else hard claimed morning Gardner yet?
pygmyhippo277 wrote:
Pygmy is not the way to go! I am a hard working tomato just trying to get some sunlight on this beautiful day!
Eat my dust.
pygmyhippo277 wrote:
Abs
Gg Hood! This is not good for town now, I have a feeling JKL is a slug and i Am still nervous about Ten’s role he has come back as.

Has anyone else hard claimed morning Gardner yet?


Personally I think jkl could be truthing, BUT has anyone else been investigated, does it tell you who the gardener is?
Eat my dust.
ThickTalon wrote:
Abs
Gg Hood! This is not good for town now, I have a feeling JKL is a slug and i Am still nervous about Ten’s role he has come back as.

Has anyone else hard claimed morning Gardner yet?

I mean. the only 2 that knew Hood was the gardener were JKL and Tenn.

I reached out to Hood as well and he gave me the "I'm a tomato...." speech. 

JKL and Tenn are suspect.

those of you thinking I am suspect, take your shot. at least you won't waste a salt on the night Gardener, but you will be one more less on against the Slugly. 
2ofclubs wrote:
Well Jkl claims being inspected again so there is away to clear him if that be true.
I also mention how JKL likes forgeries. IDk if his chat withhood is a forgery.
Ten claimed after 12pm (weak and he also claims he's not good at reading hints & clues). So is this representative or mud? It is also not normal play. But what is normal with Hood? Hood also said "I told TLM and hope it wasn't a mistake" then end up a lucky mafia kill.
Thick has been quiet after the questioning on night actions.
    
Ten knows I am town and I was on line the same time with Ten & Hood. That can make me suspicious but nothing was discussed with me so it can make Ten suspicious. Some of you know I have a truce with Ten unless he becomes scummy. He hasn't PM me since the pointing out on Thick or Hoods kill YET.
Idk but I don't believe Hood would investigate Jkl 1st over others like Anax Ten Ryo and me.
WHY would G2 investigate Jkl again. G2 would go for more info to unify town or find a slug.
Idk but there are a lot suspicious things and stuff not jiving.
WRKD4IT