I don't think restricting gametypes is a great idea - back in the day I played almost exclusively live games, and some people are really good at their favorite gametypes - they don't deserve to be excluded. However, I think finished games is a good metric. That, and as a larger issue: I see almost no officer rank people that I don't recognize from years ago. Perhaps it's too difficult to climb in terms of points nowadays?
I don't think restricting gametypes is a great idea - back in the day I played almost exclusively live games, and some people are [i]really good at[/i] their favorite gametypes - they don't deserve to be excluded. However, I think finished games is a good metric. That, and as a larger issue: I see almost no officer rank people that I don't recognize from years ago. Perhaps it's too difficult to climb in terms of points nowadays?