Mafia Game Thread
  • 911 posts
  • Page 36 of 61
BadKarma wrote:
notoriouspat
BadKarma
Interesting about JKL - I had him as slug and he did little to dispel that when confronted other than “always town” - I had begun to suspect Tennessee, so not surprised there. That No Salt strategy did nothing but remove the one and only weapon we have, our vote. Tenn played it well and was convincing. Also I would add ThickTalon into the slug category. I realize you haven’t inspected him, but he and tenn play off each other.

My question is why salt pygmy first? Why not Tennessee? He’s obviously coordinating the attack. Do you have additional info about Pygmy to prioritize him for today?

Good Question! Why Pygmy first?

I think we gotta go Tenn first for sure!
Buen Camino!
KC321 wrote:
Anaxagore wrote: 
@Abs why didn't you vote Tenn yesterday?
I don't understand

I say we vote TLM today because Abs hard claimed gardener and TLM is suspect. We have to take a calculated risk. If Tenn ends up being anything other than a slug, then we go for Abs.
Tennesseelogman wrote:
i do not think i will need to present much if any more evidence on abs - but the jkl kill as tomato should prove that i am tomato and in contact with the real gardener. if not , jkl would have contradicted me in open and PM.
Live long and prosper
Rockbert wrote:
Jkl, ThickTalon and Clubs all went No Salt at the end forcing Pygmy's salting to fail and saving him. I think Tennessee had Jkl fooled and led him to his death. Thick and Clubs may have been fooled too, even Clubs said as much, but the question here is who is going to save Tennessee today? If we all band together and salt him the slugs will come out. I still don't think that Elysium would have brought him back just to be a tomato. The slugs and the gardeners were too few to lose one that early in the game and still have balance, therefore he has to be one or the other, not a tomato. If he were the gardener then he would have PM'd someone to keep an ally close and that person would have come to his defense by now. Jkl was snowed, and believed Tennessee to the end. Tennessee is a slug, has to be. The No Salting was a genius move on his part, he is a masterful player but he has too many of us fooled. If he turns out to be the gardener then I will eat my words but I am telling you, he has played us all for fools and is leading the mafia straight to victory by picking us off one by one. Great game Tennessee. It has to stop now. #Salt Tennesseelogman.
"A writer is a person for whom writing is more difficult than it is for other people."
- Thomas Mann
BadKarma wrote:
Agree with Rockbert on this - And frankly Tennessee essentially admitted he's a slug to me in IM - so we'll take him out today and I predict the Slugs will take me out tonight.

I'm saying this now, incase I can't tomorrow once the slugs poke holes in my glorious red flesh: AFTER TLM, consider ThickTalon or Pygmy, plus make sure someone vets Anaxgore -


Buen Camino!
Tennesseelogman wrote:
well we know abs, bad, and mac are slugs . i am pretty sure on rock as slug and that kc is just falling for their scheme. but could be kc is slug and rock is just dumb as a - - -well - - you know what.
Live long and prosper
Rockbert wrote:
Tennesseelogman
well we know abs, bad, and mac are slugs . i am pretty sure on rock as slug and that kc is just falling for their scheme. but could be kc is slug and rock is just dumb as a - - -well - - you know what.

Nice try. And let's keep it respectful, no need to name call. You're better than that.
"A writer is a person for whom writing is more difficult than it is for other people."
- Thomas Mann
BadKarma wrote:
Rockbert
BK don't forget to vote
I did earlier... but here it is again

#SALT TennesseeLogMan
Buen Camino!
Tennesseelogman wrote:
BadKarma wrote:  Posted: 2 minutes ago 
Post #533
AFTER TLM, consider ThickTalon or Pygmy, plus make sure someone vets Anaxgore -
rookie mistake there - i bet your cornucopia (a group of slugs) may also point this out to you and wish you had not further identified them.
you have just named the players that you know are not in your faction = tomatoes - tlm, thick, pyg, anax
Live long and prosper
Rockbert wrote:
must be hitting pretty close to home if you're resorting to petty insults. 
"A writer is a person for whom writing is more difficult than it is for other people."
- Thomas Mann