The Dark (Mafia) - Game Thread

[quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon]Abs I am only trying to point out the facts. You have repeatedly said that your research title was gone until recently. Which is it are you earth God or researcher? If you have said I apologize it was lost in the rhetoric Talon[/quote] Read the above again especially the questions from v98, he alluded that I wasn’t any longer affiliated with Researchers when I asked but I am still concerned about protecting them as if they all die CIA win but I think my win Clause now is different and based Around Earth elements prevailing over fire [/quote] Hmm[/quote] Iv literally just given the narration of my story in every detail around how I see it, that’s all I can do, I will repeat again though even taking away the other situation with Astral elements and star signs, I have thought over and over why Clubs is protected last night, but have no logical answer so he is the one we need to Lynch as everyone who is Town can not afford another researcher dead or it’s just so high risk which I know many agree with I think this is the only key thing to think about this phase, then we all regroup and see what best course of action is tomorrow Imagine if Hood comes back as well and that is Another CIA? Can we take that risk? [/quote] You just said something that piqued my interest... "...Town can not afford another researcher dead." How do we know that the Town benefits from keeping researchers around? What if the researchers are in cahoots with the CIA?

[quote=periwinkle]Ok...this was great entertainment this week...need to retire....anyway, weekend is here for me so I won't be online as much. Also I want to get something...any piece of info....I tried to visit the yoga studio but abs and thick was there....so 4 days of nothing. Where should I go visit next without bumping into anyone?[/quote] Peri, let’s go read a book together maybe?

[quote=boomoo82][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon]Abs I am only trying to point out the facts. You have repeatedly said that your research title was gone until recently. Which is it are you earth God or researcher? If you have said I apologize it was lost in the rhetoric Talon[/quote] Read the above again especially the questions from v98, he alluded that I wasn’t any longer affiliated with Researchers when I asked but I am still concerned about protecting them as if they all die CIA win but I think my win Clause now is different and based Around Earth elements prevailing over fire [/quote] Hmm[/quote] Iv literally just given the narration of my story in every detail around how I see it, that’s all I can do, I will repeat again though even taking away the other situation with Astral elements and star signs, I have thought over and over why Clubs is protected last night, but have no logical answer so he is the one we need to Lynch as everyone who is Town can not afford another researcher dead or it’s just so high risk which I know many agree with I think this is the only key thing to think about this phase, then we all regroup and see what best course of action is tomorrow Imagine if Hood comes back as well and that is Another CIA? Can we take that risk? [/quote] You just said something that piqued my interest... "...Town can not afford another researcher dead." How do we know that the Town benefits from keeping researchers around? What if the researchers are in cahoots with the CIA? [/quote] Because we know in the original game post from v98 that the CIA win clause is to remove all Researchers Copied from page 1… [i]You are a CIA agent. You have been sent here on a life-or-death mission: [b]kill the Researchers[/b], get to the bottom of this mystery, and get the info back to the government. Whatever power is behind this, it could alter the future of mankind. However, the Researchers were one step ahead of you and are doubtless plotting your demise. Moreover, the Town is furious with anyone they can think to blame for the madness. Win clause: ___________________________[/i]

It would be really helpful to have the two perspectives clearly communicated... What is the argument for killing 2ofClubs? What is the argument for killing Abs? At this point there is a lot of distracting information in the forum, so it would nice to have the 2 arguments explained in one place...

[quote=Abs][quote=boomoo82][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon]Abs I am only trying to point out the facts. You have repeatedly said that your research title was gone until recently. Which is it are you earth God or researcher? If you have said I apologize it was lost in the rhetoric Talon[/quote] Read the above again especially the questions from v98, he alluded that I wasn’t any longer affiliated with Researchers when I asked but I am still concerned about protecting them as if they all die CIA win but I think my win Clause now is different and based Around Earth elements prevailing over fire [/quote] Hmm[/quote] Iv literally just given the narration of my story in every detail around how I see it, that’s all I can do, I will repeat again though even taking away the other situation with Astral elements and star signs, I have thought over and over why Clubs is protected last night, but have no logical answer so he is the one we need to Lynch as everyone who is Town can not afford another researcher dead or it’s just so high risk which I know many agree with I think this is the only key thing to think about this phase, then we all regroup and see what best course of action is tomorrow Imagine if Hood comes back as well and that is Another CIA? Can we take that risk? [/quote] You just said something that piqued my interest... "...Town can not afford another researcher dead." How do we know that the Town benefits from keeping researchers around? What if the researchers are in cahoots with the CIA? [/quote] Because we know in the original game post from v98 that the CIA win clause is to remove all Researchers Copied from page 1… [i]You are a CIA agent. You have been sent here on a life-or-death mission: [b]kill the Researchers[/b], get to the bottom of this mystery, and get the info back to the government. Whatever power is behind this, it could alter the future of mankind. However, the Researchers were one step ahead of you and are doubtless plotting your demise. Moreover, the Town is furious with anyone they can think to blame for the madness. Win clause: ___________________________[/i] [/quote] Ok. Excuse my newbie questions... You positing that if the CIA kills all of the researchers, they will and Town loses? I saw something about the Town also wanting to blame researchers... How do you interpret that?

*you're positing

[quote=boomoo82][quote=Abs][quote=boomoo82][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon]Abs I am only trying to point out the facts. You have repeatedly said that your research title was gone until recently. Which is it are you earth God or researcher? If you have said I apologize it was lost in the rhetoric Talon[/quote] Read the above again especially the questions from v98, he alluded that I wasn’t any longer affiliated with Researchers when I asked but I am still concerned about protecting them as if they all die CIA win but I think my win Clause now is different and based Around Earth elements prevailing over fire [/quote] Hmm[/quote] Iv literally just given the narration of my story in every detail around how I see it, that’s all I can do, I will repeat again though even taking away the other situation with Astral elements and star signs, I have thought over and over why Clubs is protected last night, but have no logical answer so he is the one we need to Lynch as everyone who is Town can not afford another researcher dead or it’s just so high risk which I know many agree with I think this is the only key thing to think about this phase, then we all regroup and see what best course of action is tomorrow Imagine if Hood comes back as well and that is Another CIA? Can we take that risk? [/quote] You just said something that piqued my interest... "...Town can not afford another researcher dead." How do we know that the Town benefits from keeping researchers around? What if the researchers are in cahoots with the CIA? [/quote] Because we know in the original game post from v98 that the CIA win clause is to remove all Researchers Copied from page 1… [i]You are a CIA agent. You have been sent here on a life-or-death mission: [b]kill the Researchers[/b], get to the bottom of this mystery, and get the info back to the government. Whatever power is behind this, it could alter the future of mankind. However, the Researchers were one step ahead of you and are doubtless plotting your demise. Moreover, the Town is furious with anyone they can think to blame for the madness. Win clause: ___________________________[/i] [/quote] Ok. Excuse my newbie questions... You positing that if the CIA kills all of the researchers, they will and Town loses? I saw something about the Town also wanting to blame researchers... How do you interpret that? [/quote] apologies for the typos... You positing that if the CIA kills all of the researchers, they win and Town loses?

[quote=boomoo82]It would be really helpful to have the two perspectives clearly communicated... What is the argument for killing 2ofClubs? What is the argument for killing Abs? At this point there is a lot of distracting information in the forum, so it would nice to have the 2 arguments explained in one place... [/quote] I want to kill 2ofClubs because he was randomly protected last night and he Had no suspicion around him, The Town Doctor who can offer protection was dead and not Around so nobody from Town was around to protect Clubs unless….he is CIA and they are all protecting each other each night. I think they can only die in day phase by being lynched Secondly, he is an Earth sign and as proven Town player Tennessee has said and I have said, we need to send Earth players Rock the Dark to keep balance as too many fire signs there Argument for me to die is: people think I am still a researcher and am Only trying to kill CIA to win, I am a zombie and am making all this up. Remember though when I first came back from the dead, I outed a CIA in Hood and made If a much safer place Town. I also didn’t have any power to stop Atrison (a researcher) dying last night, someone else killed him, likely CIA…. To me it’s obvious that clubs has to go and i Am not a danger but that’s for you all to decide

[quote=boomoo82][quote=boomoo82][quote=Abs][quote=boomoo82][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon]Abs I am only trying to point out the facts. You have repeatedly said that your research title was gone until recently. Which is it are you earth God or researcher? If you have said I apologize it was lost in the rhetoric Talon[/quote] Read the above again especially the questions from v98, he alluded that I wasn’t any longer affiliated with Researchers when I asked but I am still concerned about protecting them as if they all die CIA win but I think my win Clause now is different and based Around Earth elements prevailing over fire [/quote] Hmm[/quote] Iv literally just given the narration of my story in every detail around how I see it, that’s all I can do, I will repeat again though even taking away the other situation with Astral elements and star signs, I have thought over and over why Clubs is protected last night, but have no logical answer so he is the one we need to Lynch as everyone who is Town can not afford another researcher dead or it’s just so high risk which I know many agree with I think this is the only key thing to think about this phase, then we all regroup and see what best course of action is tomorrow Imagine if Hood comes back as well and that is Another CIA? Can we take that risk? [/quote] You just said something that piqued my interest... "...Town can not afford another researcher dead." How do we know that the Town benefits from keeping researchers around? What if the researchers are in cahoots with the CIA? [/quote] Because we know in the original game post from v98 that the CIA win clause is to remove all Researchers Copied from page 1… [i]You are a CIA agent. You have been sent here on a life-or-death mission: [b]kill the Researchers[/b], get to the bottom of this mystery, and get the info back to the government. Whatever power is behind this, it could alter the future of mankind. However, the Researchers were one step ahead of you and are doubtless plotting your demise. Moreover, the Town is furious with anyone they can think to blame for the madness. Win clause: ___________________________[/i] [/quote] Ok. Excuse my newbie questions... You positing that if the CIA kills all of the researchers, they will and Town loses? I saw something about the Town also wanting to blame researchers... How do you interpret that? [/quote] apologies for the typos... You positing that if the CIA kills all of the researchers, they win and Town loses? [/quote] Yes exactly that….this is how mafia games work, when one faction is eliminated, the other wins It’s the same in all games but just can be different set ups, for instance the one I hosted was about Narcos and gangs And once DEA killed all gang leaders they won

[quote=boomoo82][quote=Abs][quote=boomoo82][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon]Abs I am only trying to point out the facts. You have repeatedly said that your research title was gone until recently. Which is it are you earth God or researcher? If you have said I apologize it was lost in the rhetoric Talon[/quote] Read the above again especially the questions from v98, he alluded that I wasn’t any longer affiliated with Researchers when I asked but I am still concerned about protecting them as if they all die CIA win but I think my win Clause now is different and based Around Earth elements prevailing over fire [/quote] Hmm[/quote] Iv literally just given the narration of my story in every detail around how I see it, that’s all I can do, I will repeat again though even taking away the other situation with Astral elements and star signs, I have thought over and over why Clubs is protected last night, but have no logical answer so he is the one we need to Lynch as everyone who is Town can not afford another researcher dead or it’s just so high risk which I know many agree with I think this is the only key thing to think about this phase, then we all regroup and see what best course of action is tomorrow Imagine if Hood comes back as well and that is Another CIA? Can we take that risk? [/quote] You just said something that piqued my interest... "...Town can not afford another researcher dead." How do we know that the Town benefits from keeping researchers around? What if the researchers are in cahoots with the CIA? [/quote] Because we know in the original game post from v98 that the CIA win clause is to remove all Researchers Copied from page 1… [i]You are a CIA agent. You have been sent here on a life-or-death mission: [b]kill the Researchers[/b], get to the bottom of this mystery, and get the info back to the government. Whatever power is behind this, it could alter the future of mankind. However, the Researchers were one step ahead of you and are doubtless plotting your demise. Moreover, the Town is furious with anyone they can think to blame for the madness. Win clause: ___________________________[/i] [/quote] Ok. Excuse my newbie questions... You positing that if the CIA kills all of the researchers, they will and Town loses? I saw something about the Town also wanting to blame researchers... How do you interpret that? [/quote] Town blame researchers as it was them who started this mess in the first place and are Angry with them

[quote=Abs][quote=boomoo82][quote=Abs][quote=boomoo82][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon]Abs I am only trying to point out the facts. You have repeatedly said that your research title was gone until recently. Which is it are you earth God or researcher? If you have said I apologize it was lost in the rhetoric Talon[/quote] Read the above again especially the questions from v98, he alluded that I wasn’t any longer affiliated with Researchers when I asked but I am still concerned about protecting them as if they all die CIA win but I think my win Clause now is different and based Around Earth elements prevailing over fire [/quote] Hmm[/quote] Iv literally just given the narration of my story in every detail around how I see it, that’s all I can do, I will repeat again though even taking away the other situation with Astral elements and star signs, I have thought over and over why Clubs is protected last night, but have no logical answer so he is the one we need to Lynch as everyone who is Town can not afford another researcher dead or it’s just so high risk which I know many agree with I think this is the only key thing to think about this phase, then we all regroup and see what best course of action is tomorrow Imagine if Hood comes back as well and that is Another CIA? Can we take that risk? [/quote] You just said something that piqued my interest... "...Town can not afford another researcher dead." How do we know that the Town benefits from keeping researchers around? What if the researchers are in cahoots with the CIA? [/quote] Because we know in the original game post from v98 that the CIA win clause is to remove all Researchers Copied from page 1… [i]You are a CIA agent. You have been sent here on a life-or-death mission: [b]kill the Researchers[/b], get to the bottom of this mystery, and get the info back to the government. Whatever power is behind this, it could alter the future of mankind. However, the Researchers were one step ahead of you and are doubtless plotting your demise. Moreover, the Town is furious with anyone they can think to blame for the madness. Win clause: ___________________________[/i] [/quote] Ok. Excuse my newbie questions... You positing that if the CIA kills all of the researchers, they will and Town loses? I saw something about the Town also wanting to blame researchers... How do you interpret that? [/quote] Town blame researchers as it was them who started this mess in the first place and are Angry with them [/quote] My Man.......What does it matter anymore.. you have said that the earth is nonsense in the meaning of the game. If true it is earth vs. Air/Fire/Earth/Water gods.

I mean at this point the other Astral beings are sending back 2 at a time and watching and laughing. That is typical of Greek mythology, gods and thier play toys Earthlings

[spoiler][quote=boomoo82][quote=boomoo82][quote=Abs][quote=boomoo82][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon][quote=Abs][quote=ThickTalon]Abs I am only trying to point out the facts. You have repeatedly said that your research title was gone until recently. Which is it are you earth God or researcher? If you have said I apologize it was lost in the rhetoric Talon[/quote] Read the above again especially the questions from v98, he alluded that I wasn’t any longer affiliated with Researchers when I asked but I am still concerned about protecting them as if they all die CIA win but I think my win Clause now is different and based Around Earth elements prevailing over fire [/quote] Hmm[/quote] Iv literally just given the narration of my story in every detail around how I see it, that’s all I can do, I will repeat again though even taking away the other situation with Astral elements and star signs, I have thought over and over why Clubs is protected last night, but have no logical answer so he is the one we need to Lynch as everyone who is Town can not afford another researcher dead or it’s just so high risk which I know many agree with I think this is the only key thing to think about this phase, then we all regroup and see what best course of action is tomorrow Imagine if Hood comes back as well and that is Another CIA? Can we take that risk? [/quote] You just said something that piqued my interest... "...Town can not afford another researcher dead." How do we know that the Town benefits from keeping researchers around? What if the researchers are in cahoots with the CIA? [/quote] Because we know in the original game post from v98 that the CIA win clause is to remove all Researchers Copied from page 1… [i]You are a CIA agent. You have been sent here on a life-or-death mission: [b]kill the Researchers[/b], get to the bottom of this mystery, and get the info back to the government. Whatever power is behind this, it could alter the future of mankind. However, the Researchers were one step ahead of you and are doubtless plotting your demise. Moreover, the Town is furious with anyone they can think to blame for the madness. Win clause: ___________________________[/i] [/quote] Ok. Excuse my newbie questions... You positing that if the CIA kills all of the researchers, they will and Town loses? I saw something about the Town also wanting to blame researchers... How do you interpret that? [/quote] apologies for the typos... You positing that if the CIA kills all of the researchers, they win and Town loses? [/quote] [/spoiler] Boomoo, the town wins when the researchers AND CIA are dead. As I understand it, the CIA and Researchers have their own win clauses that involve taking out the other. We already have 3 dead researchers and one dead CIA. If we kill Abs, then we hand CIA the win. If we kill Clubs, he may be CIA and we can even things out a little, but if he's town, we are still relatively strong (Sorry Clubs). We cannot kill another researcher without giving the game to the CIA.

No it’s not, but it can be if The Dark gets too strong…. just need to make sure no fire are sent. the dark can be closed forever if Earth are sent to The Dark and then Earth game becomes the only one

[quote=Abs]No it’s not, but it can be if The Dark gets too strong…. just need to make sure no fire are sent. the dark can be closed forever if Earth are sent to The Dark and then Earth game becomes the only one [/quote] And you get to stay?