Romeo & Juliet Mafia - Game Thread

[quote=Anaxagore][quote=Mdhaglund]Can we talk about the lynch vote yesterday? 5 votes for Mada 4 votes for Alex (mada had 2 votes and Hood claims 2 votes, so 6 total for Alex) Alex also said 4 illegal votes were bought. If the vote was at 6-5, no way 4 votes could result in a tie. Either Alex also bought an illegal vote and didn't mention it, or possibly Hood doesnt actually have an extra vote.[/quote] I don't see a world where Alex doesn't have an extra vote every afternoon, so Hood is lying. Anyhow Alex needs to go first[/quote] Alex stated the 4 mask colors that bought votes, I would assume he would leave his out. Meaning there couldve been 5 votes that were bought which means Hood is probably telling the truth

Providing mada is neutral/and Alex not lying, why were there so many fake votes? Why would anyone spend money to save a neutral? My theory is that mafia thought in the morning someone else was in danger. Someone like Mhdaglund. I still think your PM is weird as there is no reason for a Capulet to be able to kill Montague before Juliet dies (opposite of Marion's role). My main idea idea right now is: Neutrals: Alex/Madagascarter Mafia: Hood/Mdhalung or Elysium

Hood and Elysium being outside every night kind of means they don't fear getting killed

[quote=Anaxagore]Providing mada is neutral/and Alex not lying, why were there so many fake votes? Why would anyone spend money to save a neutral? My theory is that mafia thought in the morning someone else was in danger. Someone like Mhdaglund. I still think your PM is weird as there is no reason for a Capulet to be able to kill Montague before Juliet dies (opposite of Marion's role). My main idea idea right now is: Neutrals: Alex/Madagascarter Mafia: Hood/Mdhalung or Elysium[/quote] Once again you are wrong. If people really thought I was mafia, why didnt anyone push to lynch me? Why didnt mada push for me since I admitted to killing him? Bc he knows once I am gone, it will be clear that I am Capulet. Keeping me alive keeps the suspicion on me alive. You guys keep saying to lynch a known neutral/mafia and claim that I am a known mafia so why am I still here? Mada wanted the shop before he gets outed. Mada is proven mafia/neutral

FYI, a little over 2 hours til morning. https://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20210215T220000&p0=%3A&msg=End+of+Night+5&font=cursive&csz=1#

You don't understand. These are suppositions. No one ins 100% sure you are non town. We are 100% sure Alex is not town That's why we lynched Alex. No one is afraid to lynch you. If I was bad I wouldn't mind any minute lynching you and then saying I made a mistake if you flipped town.

I see nobody has answered any of my questions as to what people are doing this night. I am running for election as socialist and checking houses. Who will speak up and say what they are doing? I expect town to be forthcoming and mafia to hide. We shall see.

[quote=Mdhaglund]Can we talk about the lynch vote yesterday? 5 votes for Mada 4 votes for Alex (mada had 2 votes and Hood claims 2 votes, so 6 total for Alex) Alex also said 4 illegal votes were bought. If the vote was at 6-5, no way 4 votes could result in a tie. Either Alex also bought an illegal vote and didn't mention it, or possibly Hood doesnt actually have an extra vote.[/quote] i also bought an illegal vote. to spend whatever left over money i had before it gets taken. i had 3 votes on alex. and alex still slips through. he's gonna win, because no one is listening.

[quote=Hoodlum][quote=Mdhaglund]Can we talk about the lynch vote yesterday? 5 votes for Mada 4 votes for Alex (mada had 2 votes and Hood claims 2 votes, so 6 total for Alex) Alex also said 4 illegal votes were bought. If the vote was at 6-5, no way 4 votes could result in a tie. Either Alex also bought an illegal vote and didn't mention it, or possibly Hood doesnt actually have an extra vote.[/quote] i also bought an illegal vote. to spend whatever left over money i had before it gets taken. i had 3 votes on alex. and alex still slips through. he's gonna win, because no one is listening. [/quote] Didnt you say you were willing to change your vote after you saw the way Anax was playing trying to defend Mada?

he, who owns the shop owns the game! ya, i heard what your saying. it's not the same as last time. yes, it is.

someone asked what my second action was? :roll:

[quote=Hoodlum]he, who owns the shop owns the game! ya, i heard what your saying. it's not the same as last time. yes, it is.[/quote] So you want Mada, who has been outed as Mafia/Neutral by me and ely (opposite houses) to have control of the shop?

[quote=Mdhaglund][quote=Hoodlum]he, who owns the shop owns the game! ya, i heard what your saying. it's not the same as last time. yes, it is.[/quote] So you want Mada, who has been outed as Mafia/Neutral by me and ely (opposite houses) to have control of the shop?[/quote] just as you want alex who admits he is neutral.? mada hasn't has he? mada would have been my lynch vote today, if alex didnt squirm thru, but he's going to keep squirming through because players that don't realise from the last time we played think it's different.

Just to be clear, me voting Mada doesnt mean I dont want Alex gone. I just view Mada as more of a threat, especially if he is the one inheriting the shop. I have voted Alex in the past and he wouldve been my next vote. I am willing to vote Alex if whoever is Lord is someone I trust. But if i do not trust the Lord, I will not vote Alex.

Right. In any split vote, the decider is always decided my the mafia. The mafia levelled it. Which means that either I am mafia, and another who voted Alex is mafia because that way mafia would get the shop. Or it means that the mafia didn’t want me to get the shop so fought with Mdhaglund to lynch me. Obvious right. No real evidence in what I’ve said so far. But here is the crunch. Didn’t Hood claim Capulet? Didn’t R4W claim Capulet and so did Mdhaglund. Those are 3 extremely rich players all voting Cap. The game would not be balanced if all these players being so rich were on the same team. I’m more inclined to believe R4W is Cap. Which means either Hood or Mdhaglund must be mafia. But Mdhaglund lied about his ability so it must be him