Romeo & Juliet Mafia - Game Thread

[quote=Anaxagore]Mada could very much be neutral if Rheisel is not. I just think it's safer to kill an official neutral (Alex) and to have more time to investigate this. If somehow Mada is lynched and is a member of my house, i will make sure there is a revenge. So if someone among you is town and is lying, he is making a big mistake.[/quote] AGAIN ALEX is ASSUMED neutral.

Alex claimed neutral many times.

[quote=rheisel]@@Anaxagore -- make this easier on all of us and tell us which house you belong to![/quote] I will when i think it's necessary. It shouldn't have an impact now. I'm just aiming at a town victory.

Okay i'm going to be honest. I don't like Mada not having a name. This looks like a neutral pm. But i also find Mdhaglund role and night actions very very unlikely.

[quote=2ofclubs][quote=rheisel][quote=Anaxagore][spoiler]Virtuosity98 said: 30 Jan 2021, 16:05 Mdhaglund You are Tybalt Capulet, cousin of Juliet Capulet, and member of the House of Capulet (Town). You are a skilled swordsman, and have a fiery personality. You hate the Montagues more than anyone else does, especially that odious Romeo. You start with 3 coins and a Sword. You earn 2 coins at the end of every afternoon phase. You can #USE a Sword on [mask colour] to kill a player each night. If the player wearing that mask colour is outside, you will attempt to kill them if they are not a Capulet. Win clause: Eliminate the House of Escalus (mafia), Romeo Montague, and all hostile neutrals, while outnumbering the House of Montague.[/spoiler] [size=16px]You can #USE a Sword on [mask colour] to kill a player each night. If the player wearing that mask colour is outside, you will attempt to kill them if they are not a Capulet. [/size] And we are suppose to believe you investigated the Lime mask and know he is not in your faction... but you didn't kill him. Oh and you didn't kill anyone else?? I mean, I told Blugotz already he should have bought a fake PM. And you should have too.[/quote] If Madagascarter has a sword (which he does): • Sword: 7 coins #KILL [mask colour] if they are outside (mafia action only). #STEAL from [mask colour] if they are outside. [b][u]Protects yourself from other Sword and Dagger users (automatic if needed).[/u][/b] #KILL WATCHMAN at [player name’s] house. [/quote] The sord appears to come with Role not purchased. Therefore has different mechanics. In light of the last few post [b]my questions is confirmed yet not answered. "Not word for word" How did you guys know to pick lime that hasn't been in play?[/b] [u]to be compounded with aprox. 30 masks in play and on the same night 2 players randomly pick Lime.[/u] If one believes that well I have a lot to sell you starting with icebergs in Central America followed with a bridge from California to Hawaii. [/quote] Idk if you are talking directly to me, or ely, or both. But I have been taking a blind shot. This was my 3rd time "investigating/attempt kill". I have crossed off the masks of those that are dead and havent been to focused on the extra masks since not many normal masks are confirmed other than those that have been killed. Without doing the math thats about 12-15ish normal masks in play. I had a 1 in 12-15 chance of blindly guessing. As for Ely, I still dont trust him. He hasnt stated his 2nd action. But I do believe he is Montague. I know Lime/Mada isnt Capulet. If Ely is telling the truth, Mada is mafia/nuetral. If Ely is lying, he is potentially trowing a Montague under the bus.

[quote=Mdhaglund]N0 Brown - not outside N1 Magenta- not outside N2 - searched housed and ran for election N3 - Stayed home N4 - Lime[/quote] @@mdhaglund -- why did you choose to #use your sword on the "lime" mask last night?

^nevermind

[quote=rheisel][quote=Mdhaglund]N0 Brown - not outside N1 Magenta- not outside N2 - searched housed and ran for election N3 - Stayed home N4 - Lime[/quote] @@mdhaglund -- why did you choose to #use your sword on the "lime" mask last night? [/quote] Completely at random accounting for my pink mask, not choosing an Extra Mask color bc few normal masks have been confirmed and I would assume if you are wearing an extra mask at night that they may have a sword. Also eliminating normal masks of dead players

[quote=Mdhaglund][quote=2ofclubs][quote=rheisel][quote=Anaxagore][spoiler]Virtuosity98 said: 30 Jan 2021, 16:05 Mdhaglund You are Tybalt Capulet, cousin of Juliet Capulet, and member of the House of Capulet (Town). You are a skilled swordsman, and have a fiery personality. You hate the Montagues more than anyone else does, especially that odious Romeo. You start with 3 coins and a Sword. You earn 2 coins at the end of every afternoon phase. You can #USE a Sword on [mask colour] to kill a player each night. If the player wearing that mask colour is outside, you will attempt to kill them if they are not a Capulet. Win clause: Eliminate the House of Escalus (mafia), Romeo Montague, and all hostile neutrals, while outnumbering the House of Montague.[/spoiler] So, if you only went outside on 2 of the 5 nights, how did you use your ability 3 times? [size=16px]You can #USE a Sword on [mask colour] to kill a player each night. If the player wearing that mask colour is outside, you will attempt to kill them if they are not a Capulet. [/size] And we are suppose to believe you investigated the Lime mask and know he is not in your faction... but you didn't kill him. Oh and you didn't kill anyone else?? I mean, I told Blugotz already he should have bought a fake PM. And you should have too.[/quote] If Madagascarter has a sword (which he does): • Sword: 7 coins #KILL [mask colour] if they are outside (mafia action only). #STEAL from [mask colour] if they are outside. [b][u]Protects yourself from other Sword and Dagger users (automatic if needed).[/u][/b] #KILL WATCHMAN at [player name’s] house. [/quote] The sord appears to come with Role not purchased. Therefore has different mechanics. In light of the last few post [b]my questions is confirmed yet not answered. "Not word for word" How did you guys know to pick lime that hasn't been in play?[/b] [u]to be compounded with aprox. 30 masks in play and on the same night 2 players randomly pick Lime.[/u] If one believes that well I have a lot to sell you starting with icebergs in Central America followed with a bridge from California to Hawaii. [/quote] Idk if you are talking directly to me, or ely, or both. But I have been taking a blind shot. This was my 3rd time "investigating/attempt kill". I have crossed off the masks of those that are dead and havent been to focused on the extra masks since not many normal masks are confirmed other than those that have been killed. Without doing the math thats about 12-15ish normal masks in play. I had a 1 in 12-15 chance of blindly guessing. As for Ely, I still dont trust him. He hasnt stated his 2nd action. But I do believe he is Montague. I know Lime/Mada isnt Capulet. If Ely is telling the truth, Mada is mafia/nuetral. If Ely is lying, he is potentially trowing a Montague under the bus.[/quote]

I think broke the text box above... @@mdhaglund -- if you only went outside on 2 of the 5 nights, how did you "investigate" for the 3rd time? This isn't adding up.

[quote=rheisel]I think broke the text box above... @@mdhaglund -- if you only went outside on 2 of the 5 nights, how did you "investigate" for the 3rd time? This isn't adding up.[/quote] Ive been outside 4 times. N0, N1, and N4 i investigated/tried to kill

[quote=rheisel]I think broke the text box above... @@mdhaglund -- if you only went outside on 2 of the 5 nights, how did you "investigate" for the 3rd time? This isn't adding up.[/quote] I am very sorry. I am misreading your previous post.

[quote=Mdhaglund]N0 Brown - not outside N1 Magenta- not outside N2 - searched housed and ran for election N3 - Stayed home N4 - Lime[/quote] The "not outside" is meant for the mask color that I was investigating. Not me.

[quote=Mdhaglund]N0 Brown - not outside N1 Magenta- not outside N2 - searched housed and ran for election N3 - Stayed home N4 - Lime[/quote] If I may rewrite so that you know I am understanding correctly, @@mdhaglund you are saying: N0 -- you went outside and used your ability on Brown - who was not outside (I didn't know this as their was no report for checking houses) N1 -- you went outside and used your ability on Magenta- who was not outside (I see this in the record) N2 - searched housed and ran for election (yes, see it.) N3 - Stayed home (yes) N4 - Lime[/quote] Okay, I think I get it. I was going down a dark path for a half second.

I'm willing to believe Mdhaglung is telling the truth. But if he is, should we also believe elsium? As 2ofclubs said, the proba of 2 people investigating the Lime mask is very low. Especially given before this night, the Lime mask was never reported by any camera... Elysium's role existing in only one house is also questionnable. I don't know who is lying in this Mada/Mdhaglund/elysium circle but i know that if we miss it's gona be bad. So why not lynch Alex and see tomorrow? Alex has poison and can kill people at night. He needs to be removed now.