The Realm of Spades mafia game thread

[quote=UltrasPlot]Actually, we do have a doctor counterclaim. We're not revealing who it is.[/quote] As I was saying, if we have counterclaims (and this is the first I am hearing about it) then we know one of the two is lying. Why not lynch someone who hasn't claimed anything and hasn't proven anything? Are you going to lynch Mad and if we find out he was telling the truth then lynch the imposter? Whoever the inspector is could easily inspect one of them. If they inspect and find out they are mafia we can tell the sheriff who can shot them that night.

We are absolutely certain that Madagascarter is the imposter.

There is at this point NO REASON for any of the 3 power roles (8-10) to remain hidden. Sure you might be the first three voted off by the mafia, but in the end we still win because there are 6 who would outlast them. 9 on 3 is no match when it is a 1 vote per side per day. We have had so many post their roles that at this point it is easier to just out everyone. For instance if there is a real doctor, don't remain hidden. Just post you are you and we can see whether Mad is correct and lynch away...you can always protect yourself as long as you want as you are invincible.. The ONLY person who should remain silent if the other power roles are not verified is the Inspector. [quote=Sygmassacre said:] 05 Aug 2017, 12:24 The 5 of Spades. dough_boy, You are a villager in the Spade Realm. You will endeavour to keep the Mafia from taking control by lynching them during the day phase. Be wary of lynching villagers though. You win when all mafia are eliminated.[/quote]

Ultrasplot is a very good mafia player and will easily manipulate things to make things go his way but when I'm doctor and you see I am... Get him

After thinking about it a little more, I think that Mad is Mafia. Initially when I caught him in a lie he claimed he was a power role which would make sense. However, it has always bothered me that when he lied to me he used "six" instead of "6" (even though I gave him "3"). I didn't put too much thought into this until I realized that maybe Syg gave out things like King, Queen, Jack instead of K of Spades, etc. So Mad had his PM Role ready to go based upon how the other things were spelled out. So based upon this logic I will #Unlynch Kyla and #Lynch Madagascarter

madag i do appreciate your efforts, if you turn to be the doc, we have another person who has also claimed it to lynch.

[quote]Are you going to lynch Mad and if we find out he was telling the truth then lynch the imposter?[/quote] Yes, this would make the most sense to do. If Mad is indeed the doctor (that would be pretty unfortunate, but doesn't look like that's the case), then the impostor should be revealed and be the one to immediately be the next to go.

There is no reason to reveal any further information today. After madag lynch I'm basically cleared (since he will flip mafia, lol); massclaim to me tonight. I want [b]timestamped,[/b] unmodified role PMs.

ULtra i am not so sure that id madag is mafia, u are basically cleared. I do not find the correlation. sorry.

1. No counterclaims to vig 2. Mathematically no, but we've been trying to get each other killed since daybreak

[quote=UltrasPlot]massclaim to me tonight. I want [b]timestamped,[/b] unmodified role PMs.[/quote] Why just to you? It should be public to everyone. Remember the Mafia knows who isn't Mafia. Yes they would like to take out Doctor and Inspector to prolong their lives, but it DOESN'T matter. You could be willing to sacrifice Mad and still be Mafia yourself...get trust amongst the village that you know what you are talking about, etc.

In that case why the hell are we counterclaiming each other and been hating on each other since the day started? Even I'm not capable of a bussing plot this elaborate in a 9v3...

He did claim vig to cheeky earlier in an attempt to off me lol.

Here is my problem. There are way too many side conversations with partial information and nothing verified. There are only 4 people I trust right now, one who claims they were inspected, the inspector (don't know who that is) skarni and myself. I believe Cheeky is ok as well. I do not trust Mad nor do I trust you Ultra. You having side conversations with random people and then trying to tell us the "real" doctor has come out doesn't help. This happened last game and it cost the Mayor her life and the Inspector when trying to let her know she had been duped.

[quote=dough_boy]Here is my problem. There are way too many side conversations with partial information and nothing verified. There are only 4 people I trust right now, one who claims they were inspected, the inspector (don't know who that is) skarni and myself. I believe Cheeky is ok as well. I do not trust Mad nor do I trust you Ultra. You having side conversations with random people and then trying to tell us the "real" doctor has come out doesn't help. This happened last game and it cost the Mayor her life and the Inspector when trying to let her know she had been duped.[/quote] Funny, you said you trusted both of us just last night.