Lordes and Ladies Mafia

1. that was a day kill 2. why would I use that night one anyways

I know. That's why I said disregard. Was still waking up, not thinking straight

lol

BETA has been supporting V98 so I would suggest V98 is clean.

So Due to the fact that OXEN and Kelly seem to be teaming up may I suggest they are mafia?

How have I teamed up with Oxen? Oxen has only said that he trusts me. AND Beta was a villager... he was clueless about who the mafia are (just like the rest of us villagers). And if I was mafia, I would have just gone with the flow and voted to lynch Beta like everyone else but I didn't. Also If you looked back in the forum you'll notice that I called someone out for unfairly accusing Beta. If I was mafia and someone accused a villager I would have kept my mouth shut.

Madagascarter seems to always assume that whenever two people have the same opinion on one matter, that they are both in league and the mafia. I don't know why he's so eager to jump to extreme conclusions...

I'm really sorry about suggesting to Lynch BETA :(. One of our good fellas :( I think myself very guilty about it, but I dont think I could have any better conclusion specially in this NOC environment :( May BETA rest in peace... I need to reread the thread a couple times to come along good conclusion about outcome of our sacrifice, but for now one thing looked interesting to me : [quote=Madagascarter - Aug 27, 12:00 PM]It appears no-one is following me by lynching Oxen. He and Kelly are still top of my suspicions list but... [b]Unlynch OXEN[/b] [b]Lynch Votazap[/b][/quote] This Post seemed a little fishy to me... It was in a situation where V98 was getting the highest tally in the votes... So we cant say this change of votes was to expedite the day progress, but it made in a stalemate between Vota and V98. I already made a wrong suspicion so I dont want to do a mistake again, but it made me think of this scenario: V98 is a mafia fellow who was getting Lynched, so his teammate Madagascarter tried to save his life by changing his vote suddenly from OXEN to Vota, making Vota and V98 in equal situation hoping to save V98. If this scenario be true, it means V98 and Madacascarter are mafiosi This post also further makes this suspicion strong : [quote=Madagascarter - Aug 27, 06:31 PM][b]Unlynch Votazap[/b] [b]Lynch BETA[/b] [/quote] Since BETA has known to be one of us. And again if it be the case, we can think the players who Madagascarter and V98 voted so far be innocent... I need you guys also to further study the thread to see if this conclusion also seems to you rational or not... We dont want to have anymore sacrifices and we need to make best out of our recent sacrifice to save the village..

[quote=Madagascarter - Aug 28, 05:25 AM]BETA has been supporting V98 so I would suggest V98 is clean.[/quote] How could we suggest a player to be innocent if an innocent player other than an inspector was supporting him? This also makes my argument stronger

[quote=Virtuosity98 - Aug 28, 06:54 AM]Madagascarter seems to always assume that whenever two people have the same opinion on one matter, that they are both in league and the mafia. I don't know why he's so eager to jump to extreme conclusions...[/quote] But this one weakens my conclusion :(. Unless we assume that Madacascarter's statements also seemed fishy to V98 and v98 tried to make it up... But V98 made this statement before my explanation, which means either my conclusion and suggested scenario is wrong or V98 is a good Mafiosi

Stratosphere, tell me this (and this completely destroys your argument): If I was mafia, and I had three votes to be lynched, and BETA had three votes to be lynched, why on earth would I not vote for BETA and save myself? I stuck with my vote for Votazap, despite there being a huge chance of me being lynched. BETA was a Townie, not a mafia, so surely me not voting for him further backs up my argument. Think it through. In summary, if I was mafia, I would have lynched BETA a) To stop myself being lynched on the tie-breaker b) To kill off a villager The fact that I did neither of these things makes it clear that I am not mafia.

Yeah I agree V98, but it doesnt make the half of my argument of you being a good mafia vanish... Madagascarter's vote made you immediately in a tie, and it is wise to not raise suspicions when you are not getting Lynched... Getting help from teammates to save you.. If you be mafia, you have three other teammates to make up the situation for you without raising suspicions directly on yourself. I agree that my scenario is not necessarily correct, but taking into account that you are probably a good mafia player, can make sense.. Dont you agree?

Could (emphasis on "could") have made sense... ...if not for this: In summary, if I was mafia, I would have lynched BETA a) To stop myself being lynched on the tie-breaker b) To kill off a villager The fact that I did neither of these things makes it clear that I am not mafia. :P

Agree emphasis on COULD.. But also remains you could be. It DOESNT make it CLEAR, but just makes my scenario work only in situations that you are a skilled and good mafiosi. Anyway its only a possible scenario and you CAN be mafia... But still you CAN be... No more and no less :P ;)

OK everyone thinks I'm a bit rash but you WILL seriously regret lynching me.