by Clarke
  • 6 posts
  • Page 1 of 1
Clarke wrote:
Here is yet another map I have finished. It is the state of Pennsylvania where I grew up.

Feedback please.

http://s41.photobucket.com/user/Richard_B_Clarke/media/D12%20Maps/PA_zps00448a41.jpg.html?sort=3&o=1
urgul wrote:
I still dont think the regions are defensible enough.... the map is looking great though!
Clarke wrote:
Carefully look at every region. Only 3 of the 16 need 4 territories to defend. One has 5, the rest have 3 and one has 2. I don't think 3 is too many to defend and that is the case for most of the map.

Also this would be a cool capitals map since many of the regions are very similar (5 defended by 3 with a 3 bonus and an interior protected cap).

I gave the regions a lot of thought and think they are good. Not going to get much better.
Dima wrote:
i recently spoke to Clarke about his maps amd sent me all he could find. One of them was pennsylvania. Seems like a normal map to me. Graphics and design are not over the top, typcal for many maps that were made 10 years ago, but not a nightmare either. I also cant see any problems with gameplay, many small regions similarly to navajo nation, mediterranean, bulgaria, germany etc...

We also could need more USA themed maps. So isnt it worth testing it?

https://imgur.com/gallery/pennsylvania-d12-ftjAf4r
"vorple: the real strategy comes when you cant just win cuz you got lucky and got the big card stack"
Dima wrote:
Dima
i recently spoke to Clarke about his mals amd sent me all he could find. One of them,was pennsylvania. Seems like a normal map to me. Graphics and design not over the top, typocal for many maps that were made 10 years ago, but not a nightmare either. I also cant see any problems with gameplay, many small regions similarly to navajo nation, mediterranean, bulgaria, germany etc...

We also could need more USA themed maps. So isnt it worth testing it?

https://imgur.com/gallery/pennsylvania-d12-ftjAf4r

Spoiler (click to show)

Somebody made a decent work and why should it go to waste?
"vorple: the real strategy comes when you cant just win cuz you got lucky and got the big card stack"
Dima wrote:
Spoiler (click to show)

i propose these gameplay changes. this way there are more big regions and less smallee. so its more balanced.


i would also re draw the map from scratch.
"vorple: the real strategy comes when you cant just win cuz you got lucky and got the big card stack"