• 545 posts
  • Page 29 of 37
Anaxagore wrote:
If Mac is scum, do we know who is the doctor?
I Haven't read much but maybe we shouldn't risk my ching the doc
Jacob24 wrote:
KC321
IrisPostTempestates
Good points Jacob - it may have been Mada being very helpful, or it's a clever tactic to gain major credibility for future rounds by sacrificing 1 Mafia early on.
Perhaps KC's claim "Me, Noto, 2oC, Rcomer, and Wolf are all confirmed town" (Post #247) is true.
But why is everyone quick to lynch Mac - because he voted to lynch Mada? So did Ely.


My claim is 100% true! It was copy/paste

I agree, it looked very legit. I was against KC for a while but now have good reason to trust him. Why is Iris throwing stuff out now?
"clubs - go suck eggs! :)"
Tennesseelogman, 2024
2ofclubs wrote:
2ofclubs
IrisPostTempestates
NO I DONT KC/TLM VERIFIED ME
I know KC verified you - but how did TLM verify you?
By my confession that was forwared to KC. 

I AM TOWN 100%
Mafia likely know my ability. Do you?    @ Iris

I posted my ROL PM less ability, chat TLM, confession, and oh my so much intel for town that mafia wouldn't do?
My biggest rival THICK is backing me.  Some of you know that THICK was never going to trust me again and has stuck with it for several games.





WRKD4IT
Jacob24 wrote:
MacEohaid
2oClubs said thank you for the protection and I responded with you're welcome and shared my ability with the town. Now everyone wants to lynch me for helping to protect our leader. Whatever. I think the mafia is probably Mada or KC or Blue.

This seems off... You call clubs "our leader" but he's the one targeting you because you won't share information? If you want to survive we're gonna need some detailed reports on how and when you've used your ability. A full role PM for Mada to confirm role and us to see ability would go a long way.
"clubs - go suck eggs! :)"
Tennesseelogman, 2024
ThickTalon wrote:
2ofclubs
IrisPostTempestates
NO I DONT KC/TLM VERIFIED ME
I know KC verified you - but how did TLM verify you?
By my confession that was forwared to KC. 

I AM TOWN 100%
Mafia likely know my ability. Do you?

I posted my ROL PM less ability, chat TLM, confession, and oh my so much intel for town that mafia wouldn't do. 
My biggest rival THICK is backing me.  Some of you know that THICK was never going to trust me again and has stuck with it for several games.





I did say that didn't I..... hmm..

Seriously though KC and TLM have verified. I have seen the TLM verification through the Board Meeting. Could it be a fake? absolutely! But with the double verification and playing long enough with TLM to see his text cadence and Clubs to see his text madness, I believe Clubs and PYG to be town.

But this is not about Clubs. Mac did respond, however ......... lackluster performance . The reality is that none of the called out 3 have really said anything with the exception of Iris. Ryo continues to be suspect.
ThickTalon wrote:
Jacob24
MacEohaid
2oClubs said thank you for the protection and I responded with you're welcome and shared my ability with the town. Now everyone wants to lynch me for helping to protect our leader. Whatever. I think the mafia is probably Mada or KC or Blue.

This seems off... You call clubs "our leader" but he's the one targeting you because you won't share information? If you want to survive we're gonna need some detailed reports on how and when you've used your ability. A full role PM for Mada to confirm role and us to see ability would go a long way.


Good point Jacob.  Reports would be nice to start. but the longer this goes on I feel like we may have another mafia....
ThickTalon wrote:
Anaxagore
If Mac is scum, do we know who is the doctor?
I Haven't read much but maybe we shouldn't risk my ching the doc


There has been no DOC claim that I can remember.
IrisPostTempestates wrote:
I know there are a lot of posts but I'm still confused by the BM (Board Meeting). What do we know about it, and why did 2ofclubs say he won't share what he knows as it could help Mafia? Rockbert was in that meeting, so we can assume he passed on any info he gathered, right?
2ofclubs wrote:
ThickTalon
Anaxagore
If Mac is scum, do we know who is the doctor?
I Haven't read much but maybe we shouldn't risk my ching the doc
BM 1:58 @ Thick - there is the aka Doc - its not a risk .

also BM 2:32 BM 1:09 BM 1:44 and the 2 wordings in ability, explains MAC i believe. TLM also put a twist on words to throw us off.
WRKD4IT
Anaxagore wrote:
Guys guys
Mac claims doc
If no one else counter claims him, let's lynch else where today.

And if he is lying, if mafia kills doc then we insta kill Mac so they probably won't which is good for us
Who else can we lynch?
ThickTalon wrote:
IrisPostTempestates
I know there are a lot of posts but I'm still confused by the BM (Board Meeting). What do we know about it, and why did 2ofclubs say he won't share what he knows as it could help Mafia? Rockbert was in that meeting, so we can assume he passed on any info he gathered, right?

The Mayor E5 called a Board Meeting night one that included E5, Rockbert, Anax, Me - I missed ALL of night one board meeting due to no reason to log in, when I logged into the the Day 2 phase and saw the PM it was too late. E5 revealed his role immediately, Anax was didn't want to reveal anything, and Rock revealed a partial role claiming Town/Civil Rights Lawyer and Win clause but no ability.

E5 called the same Board meeting for night 2 to which I was ready for and participated immediately, I revealed my entire role to the other 3 individuals, Anax again was not interested in participating (later information is that he is not fully engaged in the game), Rock and E5 were the most talkative. Rock revealed his ability night 2 and that he had investigated Mac and copied and pasted the TLM findings. We left the night without much talk of others and our suspicions due to only Rock communicating. Rock turned out Scum and more than likely killed or had E5 killed night 2.

My ability as the Grave Digger allows me to utilize the abilities of the dead 2 times during the game. I didn't want to waste and opportunity so I selected 3 people whom i felt gave us town the best options for a good robust PM. I would have liked to included more but I had to pick 3. Clubs and 2 others that do not need to be named as Mafia could target them and we don't need to have others targeted. During last nights chat All of us copied and pasted roles at different times and built a good amount of trust with other communications that we had garnered and what was already on the forum. We (painstakingly) fished through the 20+ pages of chat to find anomalies with players chats and came up with a suspect list. THIS LIST IS NOT WRITTEN ON A GOLDEN TABLET, but it is very likely from research that these individuals are not town. 

IF you are suspect you will be called out and expected to prove yourself. Could we be wrong........? Absolutely, however with the help of investigators and findings we felt we had a good list to start off of.

Below is my full role from TLM, take it for what it is worth or how you want:

Spoiler (click to show)