• 545 posts
  • Page 10 of 37
Tennesseelogman wrote:
as of now w 2 hours to go before the deadline, the vote count is

no lynch - 3 - blue, anu, kc
mada - 3 -anax, ely, rock

abstain - 6 - 2oc, thick, mac, mada, npat, cry = will not count in the final tally
not voted - 4 - iris, ryo, pyg, rc = will not count in the final tally

the lynch will be decided by 6 players
Live long and prosper
Bluegoetz wrote:
Rockbert wrote:  Posted: 21 minutes ago 
Post #135
I am willing to believe that KC is town but that he's just stumbled a bit maybe. Not sure. I could be wrong, but for now I am going to trust Elysium and Anax and go with #Lynch Mada. I reserve the right to switch before deadline.

this is odd i think, given ely has said hello and lynch mada, and anax said his vote is based on a feeling and absent post. and you "are going to trust them"?
plus you said this:
 Rockbert wrote:  Posted: 02 Nov 2023, 19:05 
Post #60
ThickTalon
Without PM's this is a tight game for Town. Mafia has the high advantage early in the game. Take your time with your lynch vote. Make sure you are not just jumping on a wagon. Look at who is voting for who, make your own decisions don't be lazy. Town has 2 advantages on our side numbers and time, use the most of it.

That said

#Abstain

Well said Thick.

blind lynch day one is bad idea.
anax vote and his reasoning may check out because he said it first, but rock and ely feel like bandwagon with all the abstains
Anaxagore wrote:
Jacob24
#Lynch KC321

I know it won't pass but I need answers from him

KC seems obvious town for me as he claimed some kind of investigative role day 1, also no kill tonight means he was maybe saved.

But i don't see mafia going after town cop like this so i'll put you in the town pile for now
2ofclubs wrote:
#NO LYNCH
My read is KC stumbled.
Mafia will vote with no fear of friendly fire. Note 2 of the votes are from soft and no substance town claims.
Also mafia wouldn't let KC go roug.
I am protected so I am ok with no lynch vs hitting a friendly. I am on the same page against Mada. But Anax vote switch is a concern. We also don't know if somebody has vote manipulation. As Thick said we have time. Losing a town tonight is better than being down 2 from friendly fire.
#NO LYNCH

Who are the aledged target for town killer if there is one?
WRKD4IT
MacEohaid wrote:
KC and Mada are high on my list of suspects, but I am following 2oC's lead for now.
KC321 wrote:
I don’t see how I stumbled at all. If not for my input we would be completely in the dark still because there are no PM. At this point I’m the game, I know more than everyone who is not mafia. You’re just a bit salty that I won’t share my role, or the 3rd confirmed town
Bluegoetz wrote:
KC321 wrote:  Posted: 3 minutes ago 
Post #144
I don’t see how I stumbled at all. If not for my input we would be completely in the dark still because there are no PM. At this point I’m the game, I know more than everyone who is not mafia. You’re just a bit salty that I won’t share my role, or the 3rd confirmed town

I cant speak for everyone, but for me i'm confused on how you got this information to start?
why during a day phase with seemingly no abilities at play do you know someone is town?
but tn does throw things like that in, one time uses or start with certain information, so I hold out to see what comes of your information. doesn't seem like a smart mafia move to share. but neither does using a one time ability right off the bat to check Noto.
2ofclubs wrote:
Anaxagore
investigate Rockbert or 2ofclubs tonight
If your town your waisting an inspect on me. If your mafia you want to know my ability. 
WRKD4IT
2ofclubs wrote:
Bluegoetz
KC321 wrote:  Posted: 3 minutes ago 
Post #144
I don’t see how I stumbled at all. If not for my input we would be completely in the dark still because there are no PM. At this point I’m the game, I know more than everyone who is not mafia. You’re just a bit salty that I won’t share my role, or the 3rd confirmed town

I cant speak for everyone, but for me i'm confused on how you got this information to start?
why during a day phase with seemingly no abilities at play do you know someone is town?
but tn does throw things like that in, one time uses or start with certain information, so I hold out to see what comes of your information. doesn't seem like a smart mafia move to share. but neither does using a one time ability right off the bat to check Noto.
It was stated no kills the 1st 2 phases with nothing said about other abilities. IMO.
WRKD4IT
Jacob24 wrote:
Crywolf
im assuming there are more than 1 investigator because otherwise my role is awful, probably 2-3 at least
im saying this because my ability just notifies me when a Townie has made an investigation. Maybe KC is out of pocket right now and im also not ready to say he's mafia, but I did not receive a notification saying that someone had made an investigation on Day 0...

Maybe someone can help me understand b/c it's my first game, but wouldn't this seem to directly contradict KC? Also, isn't KC claiming he's run 3 investigations now? In my mind that suggests that either Crywolf or KC are lying about something.
"clubs - go suck eggs! :)"
Tennesseelogman, 2024