The shading is better, though I would like to see a version with the shading a bit darker for comparison.
I hadn't actually taken a hard look at this map until now. I think some people might be confused by the region bonuses legend.
The colors in the legend correspond to the color of the territory name labels in those regions. Traditionally it's the color of the territory and not the color of the label that is used. Also, the map doesn't even follow this strictly. The labels for Brisbane and the Darling Downs aren't the same color. Another example is Adelaide and Woodmera.
I would like to see this map use the traditional color scheme. The color in the regions list should match the color of that region. I also think that it would look better if the territory labels were not part of the color scheme and just used the best color for contrast so that they are more readable. Black, yellow and white look best on this map. You should stick to those.
And about colors, another issue I have is with the similarity of colors between Queensland and south Australia. It might look better if Queensland was more brown.
I also think that the map would look better if the green color used for Tasmania was more dominant. you could try switching the color with a bigger region.
It would also look better if the red, brown, and yellowish tan regions weren't so close together. and the two blues weren't next to each other too.
Here's a proposal:
Tasmania: Black
Victoria: Red
Sidney: the same - Cyan
Queensland - orange-tan
South Australia - green
Northern territory - blue
Western Australia - brown
I also wonder if the territory boundaries can be modified even more. I assume that the territories include parts of the ocean because initially it was faster and easier to draw lazy borders. Is there another reason that the territories include parts of the ocean? I think that this is fine for Tasmania but I would like to see the territory borders match the coastline for the others. This map would look a lot better if the borders were exactly like that map I showed you in that message I sent.
I haven't had a chance to think hard about the region bonuses, i will do that later.
I know that this post will be discouraging for you because it would be a lot of work but the map is just not ready as it stands.
At a very minimum the issue about the colors in the region bonus legend matching the territory label colors and not the territory colors themselves needs to be resolved.
The shading is better, though I would like to see a version with the shading a bit darker for comparison.
I hadn't actually taken a hard look at this map until now. I think some people might be confused by the region bonuses legend.
The colors in the legend correspond to the color of the territory name labels in those regions. Traditionally it's the color of the territory and not the color of the label that is used. Also, the map doesn't even follow this strictly. The labels for Brisbane and the Darling Downs aren't the same color. Another example is Adelaide and Woodmera.
I would like to see this map use the traditional color scheme. The color in the regions list should match the color of that region. I also think that it would look better if the territory labels were not part of the color scheme and just used the best color for contrast so that they are more readable. Black, yellow and white look best on this map. You should stick to those.
And about colors, another issue I have is with the similarity of colors between Queensland and south Australia. It might look better if Queensland was more brown.
I also think that the map would look better if the green color used for Tasmania was more dominant. you could try switching the color with a bigger region.
It would also look better if the red, brown, and yellowish tan regions weren't so close together. and the two blues weren't next to each other too.
Here's a proposal:
Tasmania: Black
Victoria: Red
Sidney: the same - Cyan
Queensland - orange-tan
South Australia - green
Northern territory - blue
Western Australia - brown
I also wonder if the territory boundaries can be modified even more. I assume that the territories include parts of the ocean because initially it was faster and easier to draw lazy borders. Is there another reason that the territories include parts of the ocean? I think that this is fine for Tasmania but I would like to see the territory borders match the coastline for the others. This map would look a lot better if the borders were exactly like that map I showed you in that message I sent.
I haven't had a chance to think hard about the region bonuses, i will do that later.
I know that this post will be discouraging for you because it would be a lot of work but the map is just not ready as it stands.
At a very minimum the issue about the colors in the region bonus legend matching the territory label colors and not the territory colors themselves needs to be resolved.