The Witch's Coven Gameplay Thread

[quote]That is actually a pretty Town-looking move from Tenn. [/quote] thanks for noticing gpt

no robbery unfortunately. i've still got 3 accusations, alibi and scapegoat. can't use any of them until stocks wears off though.

clubs - you may disagree w my assessment - but i would play your alibi on hood. i am full bore on vic and jacob now

Current accusation counts ​Goryh 0 marks 4 tryal cards Hoodlum 6 marks 2 tryal cards. STOCKS (8:30 AM SERVER TIME) Vicious 0 marks 3 tryal cards ​Tennesseelogman 0 marks 4 tryal cards ​Notoriouspat ​0 marks 2 tryal cards PIETY, BLACK CAT 2ofclubs 0 marks 2 tryal cards Crywolf ​0 marks 3 tryal cards Jacob24 3 marks 4 tryal cards ASYLUM Akkila 0 marks 4 tryal cards Please self track the cards that you have left to play. I will go back and look if needed but I really do not want to. The witches are comming. The witches are comming

[quote=Tennesseelogman]clubs - you may disagree w my assessment - but i would play your alibi on hood. i am full bore on vic and jacob now[/quote] Well we play well as a team on maps w/o friction. [u]I would like to know why hood chose Jacob.[/u] Over all i am on board but also not saying hood is town. ;)

Also who put Asylum on Jacob.

[quote=2ofclubs]Also who put Asylum on Jacob.[/quote] Neat on Ten, then Hood moved to Jacob.

i (gpt) didn't choose jacob because of asylum. i (gpt) chose tenn's pile because it was the useful legal pile i could move. jacob was where i dumped it. jacob was basically a random destination.

I think that we shouldnt flip anyones last card Because when 4 are flipped if they are flipped randomly there is 80% chance that the witch card is flipped if the player is a witch. but if the last card is flipped witches are closer to winning. Remember that Eveyy card has a same chance of being a witch so rather flip a card that is on player eith more cards than one.

I am suspicious of Akkila and Vicious, so I can support accusing Vicious (though I can't until I get new cards). The withes tried to kill Jacob the first night so he can't be a witch unless we think the darkness is spreading and he is a new witch. Because I am about to go to bed and want to not waste my last card (like I did yesterday): [b]#Stocks on Vicious[/b]

Current accusation counts ​Goryh 0 marks 4 tryal cards Hoodlum 6 marks 2 tryal cards. STOCKS (8:30 AM SERVER TIME) Vicious 0 marks 3 tryal cards. STOCK (2:30 PM SERVER TIME) ​Tennesseelogman 0 marks 4 tryal cards ​Notoriouspat ​0 marks 2 tryal cards PIETY, BLACK CAT 2ofclubs 0 marks 2 tryal cards Crywolf ​0 marks 3 tryal cards Jacob24 3 marks 4 tryal cards ASYLUM Akkila 0 marks 4 tryal cards Please self track the cards that you have left to play. I will go back and look if needed but I really do not want to. The witches are comming. The witches are comming

[size=16px][b][i][u]Vicious you are in stocks. You can not play cards until 2:30 pm server time.[/u][/i][/b][/size] You may post in the thread

Anyone have 1 accusation left to put on hood to flip another card?

Hood asking GPT.. "so i kind of understand pat would be annoyed because of my moving the asylum thing on jacob. did the witches try and kill jacob n1? why would that make me sus to pat/clubs/tenn?" [spoiler] Yes — [b]Goryh is right on that point. The Witches tried to kill Jacob on Night 1, and Jacob survived because he was protected.[/b] Tenn explicitly went back to the Night 1 report and confirmed that distinction earlier. So the timeline matters: [b]Night 1[/b]: Witches target [b]Jacob [/b]→ protection saves Jacob. [b]End of Day 2[/b]: you Scapegoat Tenn's pile onto Jacob → Jacob receives [b]Tenn's Asylum[/b]. Night 2: no Witch kill occurs, apparently because the Coven didn't reach unanimous agreement. That means [b]Jacob could not reasonably have been one of the original Witches on Night 1[/b]—they were trying to kill him. However, because of the Conspiracy mechanic, Jacob [b]could have become a Witch later[/b] if he subsequently received a Witch Tryal card. So Tenn's present-day Jacob suspicion isn't impossible; it just means Jacob would have to be a [b]converted/new Witch[/b], not an original one. And yes, this makes Pat's frustration with your Scapegoat play much easier to understand. From Pat's perspective, you moved [b]Asylum onto someone the Witches had already demonstrated they wanted dead[/b]. That inadvertently gave Jacob continued protection. But crucially: [b]we didn't know any of this when we picked Jacob as the destination[/b]. Jacob was basically arbitrary; our strategic decision was about moving Tenn's pile, not protecting Jacob. So I soften my Pat read too. His wanting another Hood flip may partly be: “Hoodlum accidentally protected the Witch target!” :) rather than Witch behaviour. The really interesting question now is [b][b]whether Jacob could have received a Witch card in a Conspiracy after Night 1[/b][/b]. If we reconstruct exactly what happened to Jacob's Tryal cards during each Conspiracy, we may be able to assess how plausible the “converted Jacob” theory actually is.[/spoiler]

Voting gpt as mvp. Lol