Map Maker Help

what to work on
  • 21 posts
  • Page 2 of 2
Matty wrote:
Its difficult to compare you two, but you are both making awesome maps.

So keep up the good work!
"Strength doesn't lie in numbers, strength doesn't lie in wealth. Strength lies in nights of peaceful slumbers." ~Maria
marcoxa wrote:
@matty yea i am going to continue Keeva shortly. school started and everything with it so i got busy fast. but things are cooling down now so i hope to get back to it soon. :)

good job with the rankings btw. i tallied up the points to compare. i think its pretty accurate.

marcoxa: 42/55
Thorpe: 54/60
Pntbttr: 54/60


should we have all the map makers rate eachother then avg to get a final number?
Matty wrote:
I deliberately didnt calculate the average.

Not because I'm too lazy (well, at least, not solely for that), but because its very hard to compare ppl, and as Bishop said, in this way of rating graphics count too much over things like gameplay and idea.
"Strength doesn't lie in numbers, strength doesn't lie in wealth. Strength lies in nights of peaceful slumbers." ~Maria
Pntbttr wrote:
Cool I got an average of 54/60! Now I need to work at getting that last 6. Do all my maps really look that similar? I guess I need to work on that...
Leedog wrote:
Top 5 Map Makers (all have skill and standards):

1. Vexer
2. Noxon
3. Glanru
4. Thorpe
5. Pntbttr

Top 5 Maps:

1. Africa - Perfect in every way
2. Oregon Cities - Best texture
3. Westeros - Challenging
4. World Expanded - Stylish
5. New York City - Concept

Bottom 5 Maps:

1. Jungle - Style below standards
2. Realm of Honored - Computer generated look
3. Basketball - Confusing
4. Eastern Asia - Inaccurate
5. Caribbean - Drab colors

(Eld World update has kept map off the 'Bottom' list)

Don't mean to offend anyone, just stating my humble opinions!!